Skip to content
Dark blue background with "The Dispatch Podcast" written in red and white serif font. The tone is professional and polished.

Can Redistricting Lead to a GOP Midterm Victory?

Listen on your player of choice

Mike Warren is joined by Jonah Goldberg, David Drucker, and Charles Hilu to discuss the nationwide redistricting battles happening in state legislatures and Donald Trump’s low approval for handling inflation.

The Agenda:

Dispatch Recommendations:

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Michael Warren is politics editor at The Dispatch and is based in Washington, D.C. A former on-air reporter at CNN and a senior writer at The Weekly Standard, he has spent more than 15 years covering lawmakers on Capitol Hill, the White House and the executive branch, the conservative movement, and political campaigns. When Mike is not reporting, writing, editing, and podcasting, he is probably spending time with his wife and three sons.

Jonah Goldberg is editor-in-chief and co-founder of The Dispatch, based in Washington, D.C. Prior to that, enormous lizards roamed the Earth. More immediately prior to that, Jonah spent two decades at National Review, where he was a senior editor, among other things. He is also a bestselling author, longtime columnist for the Los Angeles Times, commentator for CNN, and a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. When he is not writing the G-File or hosting The Remnant podcast, he finds real joy in family time, attending to his dogs and cat, and blaming Steve Hayes for various things.

David M. Drucker is a contributing writer and former senior writer at The Dispatch. He is also a Bloomberg Opinion columnist and MS NOW contributor.

Charles Hilu is a reporter for The Dispatch based in Washington, D.C. Before joining the company in 2024, he was the Collegiate Network Fellow at the Washington Free Beacon and interned at both National Review and the Washington Examiner. When he is not chasing down lawmakers on Capitol Hill, he is probably listening to show tunes or following the premier sports teams of the University of Michigan and city of Detroit.

The podcast transcription below was generated using artificial intelligence and may include occasional errors or misspellings.

Mike Warren

[upbeat music] Welcome to the Dispatch Podcast. I'm Mike Warren. On today's roundtable, we'll discuss the recent Supreme Court decision on the Voting Rights Act and the state redistricting battles happening across the country. We'll also discuss the state of the economy one year into Trump's second term and two and a half months into the Iran war, and what it all means for Trump's popularity and the long-projected Democratic victory in the upcoming midterms. Then finally, Not Worth Your Time, have we reached peak bagel? I'm joined today by my Dispatch colleagues Jonah Goldberg, David Drucker, and Charles Hilles. Let's dive in. [upbeat music] All right, well let's talk about this strange convergence of all kinds of events and things that have been happening really over the last year or so. It started with Texas and President Donald Trump encouraging the Republican legislature there to redistrict mid-decade and give Republicans an edge in the House of Representatives by giving Republicans five more seats from Texas. There was a response, of course, from California. Gavin Newsom did the same thing in California, getting behind this referendum, which passed in 2025 on Election Day. And then it was off to the races with all these other states. You had Democratic-led states trying to redistrict mid-decade to add more Democratic seats, Republican states doing the same thing, a tit for tat back and forth. Indiana, their Republicans sort of stood on principle in the state Senate and said no. Uh, and of course, m- recently, last week, we saw a number of those state senators lose their primaries thanks to some backing from Trump and the Republican establishment, who was not happy with that. You had Virginia, the Democratic legislature there pushing through a referendum that passed to be able to allow Virginia to redraw those districts and have 10 Democratic-leaning districts to just one Republican district in that state. Then we, of course, we saw the state Supreme Court overturn that decision from Virginia. So there's this whole mess of stuff going on where states are redistricting or getting slapped down or somehow roadblocks being put up for all of that. How is it going to shake out? That seems to be a question that we can discuss here today. But then you throw in these other developments, particularly from the Supreme Court, this recent ruling, this Calley decision from the Supreme Court essentially holding that, and this is from our friends at SCOTUSblog, the Voting Rights Act of 1965 did not require the state of Louisiana to create an additional majority-minority district. No compelling interest justified the state's use of race in creating that map, and that map is an unconstitutional racial gerrymander. So this was involving a map in Louisiana that had been sort of drawn a really kinda ugly gerrymander to get in one minor- majority-minority district, a Black district that is likely to go Democratic. The Supreme Court ruling essentially that map, y- you know, was, it was not, Louisiana was not required to create a, an additional district like that, and the floodgates seemed to be open in a bunch of these Southern states that were compelled by the Voting Rights Act to create these majority-minority districts. So now you've seen a number of states with Republican legislatures trying to also redistrict, create new maps that are drawing out Democratic districts, drawing in new Republican districts. All this is all happening, well, I don't know. [laughs] We're in the middle of a midterm election. There are primaries going on. There's a question about what Louisiana was going to do with a primary election that's happening this Saturday, just, you know, a day after this podcast goes live. So the state of Louisiana has moved the House primary. The Senate primary, which is not affected by this redistricting, is, is going on still on Saturday. Anyway, it's a whole big mess. Charles, explain to us sort of what's happening right now in these states, Tennessee, South Carolina, Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, Georgia, Florida. There's all these different Southern states, and they're kinda taking different tacks. What's actually happening? What are they doing to change their maps or not change their maps at this critical moment?

Charles Hilu

Sure thing, Mike. Several Southern states, as you brought up in response to the Calley decision, they moved to eliminate some of their majority-minority districts. You know, Louisiana, of course, because their map was struck down by the court. They were put in kind of a darned-if-you-do-darned-if-you-don't situation where if they had used, gone ahead and used the maps and s- that the court struck down and they said it was too late to change the maps, then they would've gotten criticism that they were using unconstitutional maps, and the election would've been seen by many as illegitimate. But instead, what they did do is, as you said, they delayed their House primaries, and now they're getting criticism about causing voter confusion and all of this stuff. The latest I just saw is it looks like the Senate is going to vote on a map, uh, which will eliminate one of the two majority Black districts. It looks like it's Cleo Fields' district that is on the chopping block.

Mike Warren

In Louisiana

Charles Hilu

In Louisiana, yes. So in Louisiana, he's a freshman congressman. It looks like his district is on the chopping block, and that will add, in total, one more Republican district. Tennessee, in response to Calley, also did something similar where they had a majority-minority district around Memphis represented by Steve Cohen, and they carved up his district. That's been signed by the governor. A- again, one more Republican seat. And then Alabama, of course, they were kinda the most questionable as to whether they would actually be able to pull this off because they had this court injunction, or this court stay, this court order that said that they weren't allowed to change their maps before the end of the decade with the new census after 2030. They appealed to the Supreme Court, and the court actually granted them relief from that court order, and now they, it looks like they're set to, uh, again eliminate one of their two majority-minority districts. And that, again, is going to give Republicans one more House seat. But the most interesting one is South Carolina where this week the State Senate, they didn't have a two- a super majority to call to allow them to stay in session for a little longer this month and consider redistricting. And I think the speech that the Senate majority leader gave, a guy named Shane Massey in South Carolina, I think his speech is sort of worth unpacking because it's a very comprehensive case against redistricting, both on the practical and pragmatic level, but also on the principle level. So he starts off with the reason why it might not be very practical to do redistricting because he s- he, he sort of makes the argument that you can't really squeeze any more Republican seats out of South Carolina. It has a six-one congressional delegation right now, and he said if you try and get too cute, you could actually make it five-two. And the reason for that is that if you carve up a Democratic stronghold, a Democratic district, you're going to need to put those Democratic voters somewhere, and though you're gonna have to put them into Republican districts. So that could dilute the districts of the incumbent Republicans, and they're gonna have to work a little harder.

Mike Warren

Yeah. I want to return to Massey's speech in a little bit, but let's stick on this point, David Drucker, because this is the kind of gamble, I suppose [laughs], that these Republican legislatures that are deciding, unlike South Carolina, are deciding at this moment to sort of redraw these districts. Are they Democratic districts that Republicans are gerrymandering out of existence, or are they Black majority districts and are Republicans sort of, you know, denying Black representation in Congress? It gets complicated because that Tennessee district around Memphis that Charles mentioned, which is a majority Black district, has been represented for a very long time by a white Democrat. And so there are questions about that. But to Charles's point and to this, this leader in South Carolina's point, Shane Massey, if you draw out to maximize sort of Republican representation, you end up not only diluting out of existence majority-minority districts in the South, but you dilute Republican districts as well to the point where you're not talking about R plus 15, you know, advantages. It might be R plus 10 or R plus 8 or R plus 5. And that isn't necessarily a guarantee that district is going to remain Republican from here on out. Is this a gamble some of these legislatures are making, or is this just, you know, smart and ruthless politics?

Interactive transcripts are available to Premium members. Join to follow along with the audio.

Join Now

More We Think You’d Like

Loading