Members can share articles with friends & family to bypass the paywall.
Sarah Isgur and David French discuss the emergency docket ruling from SCOTUS on Alabama’s congressional maps, which broke down over three-justice ideological lines, Virginia’s filing (yes, they did file) at the Supreme Court, and a very special 2-1 9th Circuit panel opinion.
The Agenda:
–Central, urban bonkerstown
–14th Amendment Equal Protection argument vs. Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act
–Virginia files gerrymandering case at SCOTUS
–Would You Rather: Due Process Clause or Equal Protection Clause?
Show Notes:
Advisory Opinions is a production of SCOTUSblog and The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a nonpartisan perspective. Click here to sign up for our new Advisory Opinions newsletter, and click here to access all of The Dispatch’s offerings, including audio versions of all our articles and newsletters. If you’d like to remove all ads from your podcast experience, consider becoming a premium Dispatch member by clicking here.
Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?
Add Us as a Preferred SourceThe podcast transcription below was generated using artificial intelligence and may include occasional errors or misspellings.
You ready?
I was born ready.
[upbeat music]
Welcome to Advisory Opinions. I'm Sarah Isgur, that's David French. We have a emergency docket, interim docket ruling from the Supreme Court about Alabama's congressional maps. Remember Allen v. Milligan? Well, guess what? They've sent it back over a three-justice dissent along ideological lines. We're gonna break it down. Who got that one right, and what happens now? Plus, Virginia actually did file at the US Supreme Court. Is it as central urban bonkers town as David and I predicted? And a very special two to one Ninth Circuit panel opinion that will define who you are as a judge on that Y-axis, the institutionalism thing we've been talking about. Are you a Kavanaugh or are you a Gorsuch? Uh, plus an idea from Jesse Wegman at the Brennan Center, should we raise the bar for the Supreme Court to strike down an act of Congress? Why are we doing this five-four stuff? Let's make it seven-two? Uh, and lastly, a special would you rather. Due process clause or equal protection clause? You can only pick one. All this and more on Advisory Opinions. David, let's start with, I mean, we're back to Calais. We're still doing redistricting at the Supreme Court, this time Alabama. This is the state that had Allen versus Milligan a couple years ago, where the Supreme Court said, "Uh, nope, that looks like a Section 2 violation to us." And we did lots of podcasts on it, and Alabama was told to go back and draw another majority-minority district. Alabama politely declined to do that and kept saying, "Nope, we will only draw one district." It went back to the three-judge panel, and that three-judge panel was, um, annoyed, and not only said that they were still violating Section 2 because, you know, the Supreme Court said so, but also that they were in violation now of the 14th Amendment due pro- I mean, Equal Protection Clause because they had refused to follow the Supreme Court and that panel's decision that they violated Section 2 by not drawing a second majority-minority district. So Calais comes out, Alabama goes to the Supreme Court and is like, "How do you like me now? Can we please stick with our maps that we had?" And the Supreme Court has sent it back to the lower court, vacating the lower court's decision and allowing Alabama to use its old/new single majority, uh, minority district map for, I would say this election, but that gets kind of messy, David, because it affects some districts and not others. And what the governor of Alabama has said is they will continue with the May 19th primary for the districts that aren't affected, and they will hold a new primary August 11th for the districts that are affected. Talk about a hot mess. There was-- This was six-three. We had dissents, one dissent, but it was written by Justice Sotomayor, joined by Justices Kagan and Jackson. This is where we're gonna have to, like, go back and explain the 14th Amendment Equal Protection Clause lawsuits about racial gerrymandering versus the Voting Rights Act Section 2 lawsuits about opportunity districts because the dissent says, "Hey, guys, uh, we disagree with this for all, you know, we disagree with Calais," right? But even with Calais, it's still a mistake to vacate this because Calais only has to do with Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act, but here, that three-judge panel found that this wasn't just a Section 2 violation. They found that it was a constitutional violation under the 14th Amendment, so therefore they, there were alternative grounds that have nothing to do with Calais. Why in the world are we vacating this to cause absolute chaos in Alabama? And David, I was like, "Uh, yeah, that seems like a really good point. I don't understand why the majority would do this." Now, yes, that three-judge panel could just once again find there's a constitutional violation, but, like, we're out of time. By the time they do that, I mean, we're in total nonsense territory here. So David, [chuckles] I went back last night, and look, I wanna be very clear, I am by no means an expert on all of the record findings in this Alabama case. The appendix is 561 pages. Okay, the 14th Amendment Equal Protection Clause means that you cannot racially gerrymander a district. You cannot use race for the purpose of diluting someone's vote because of their race. Racial gerrymandering, not allowed under the 14th Amendment. And so you're thinking, "Wait a second. Isn't that exactly what Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act requires?" And it's like, yeah, actually kind of required, let's say pre-Calais. But basically, think about it like strict scrutiny, David. Section 2 allows you to overcome strict scrutiny if you are using race for the purpose of drawing an opportunity district. But y- we saw these lawsuits all the time. Some would be brought under Section 2 of the Voting Rights Act saying, "You must use race to draw an opportunity district," and some, that would be the, like, we want you to pack voters in, and some would be brought under the 14th Amendment Equal Protection Clause under racial gerrymandering saying, "No, no, you cracked the districts. You split up a community of interest, uh, in order to dilute m- uh, minority voters," and that's racial gerrymandering. That's not allowed under the 14th Amendment. UmIf this three-judge panel really did find that they violated both Section 2 and the 14th Amendment,
the d- the dissent would be totally right. It doesn't matter what Calais said because there's a 14th Amendment violation anyway. But
Interactive transcripts are available to Premium members. Join to follow along with the audio.
Join Now



