Skip to content

Our Best Stuff on Redistricting and Primaries

What a Republican primary in Kentucky and a Democratic race in Iowa tell us about the state of the respective parties.
Rachael Larimore /
A middle-aged man with a gray beard wearing a dark blue suit and patterned tie speaks outdoors with a blurred background of trees and buildings.
Rep. Thomas Massie arrives for a news conference outside the Capitol on November 18, 2025. (Photo by Heather Diehl/Getty Images)

Hello and happy Saturday. My own state’s primary on Tuesday wasn’t exactly exciting or surprising—we’ve known for months that Republican Vivek Ramaswamy would face Democrat Dr. Amy Acton for Ohio governor, and former Democratic Sen. Sherrod Brown would challenge Sen. Jon Husted in a special election for Vice President J.D. Vance’s former Senate seat. That left all eyes on Indiana, where the national headlines were about … the state Senate. No, really. 

Last fall, Indiana Gov. Mike Braun called a special session of the General Assembly in an attempt to redraw the state’s congressional map at President Donald Trump’s behest. Eight Republican state senators refused to go along with the ploy, and the measure failed. They were rewarded with primary challenges, with Trump explicitly endorsing seven candidates. The president’s approval rating might be cratering, but his endorsement—and financial backing from groups aligned with him—still carries a lot of weight. Six of the eight challengers won their races, one incumbent survived, and one race is still too close to call with the candidates separated by a handful of ballots. (Last month, David M. Drucker traveled to Indiana to report on these races; his piece is worth a re-read for understanding the state’s dynamics.)

Trump’s ability to influence voters will be a recurring theme throughout our coverage of the midterms. Countless politicians who’ve crossed the president in one way or another have retired or lost reelection. The party is effectively in the grip of MAGA. So who is left and how will they fare this fall? 

To help answer that question, we sent Drucker back out on the road, this time to Kentucky. Thomas Massie has represented the state’s 4th Congressional District since 2012 and has always cruised to reelection, but the libertarian-leaning Republican has drawn the president’s ire with votes against defense spending packages, aid to Israel, the farm bill, and notably, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act in 2025. But Massie’s biggest affront to Trump might be his push to get the Epstein files released. Drucker details how Massie and a handful of House Republicans worked with Democrats on the Epstein Files Transparency Act, which ended up passing 427-1 in the House and unanimously in the Senate. By the time Trump signed it into law on November 19, he’d already lined up dairy farmer and military veteran Ed Gallrein to challenge Massie. And no one is quite sure how the May 19 primary will go. Drucker writes:

With the primary close enough to be measured in furlongs, Massie supporters are confident. The congressman’s northern Kentucky detractors, while hopeful, are dogged by doubts about voter turnout and unwilling to predict that Trump and his allies will succeed. So, which camp is more likely to be smiling on primary eve? Some of the most seasoned political observers in the area are having a hard time figuring that out.

“I can’t get a pulse on it. Usually I can predict it—90 percent of the time,” Rodney Eldridge, a veteran political hand here and the former elected Kenton County clerk, told The Dispatch as he was exiting the Lincoln Day Dinner. Eldrige, 67, is neutral in the primary. “I haven’t seen an election like this in a long time, and I’ve been doing this since I was 12 years old.”

The Democrats, of course, face their own internal issues. The party’s progressive faction is vocal, active, and demanding, often to the party’s detriment: The Biden administration’s support for Israel in its war against Hamas has been cited as a reason Kamala Harris lost the 2024 election. Progressives fight tooth-and-nail for causes like allowing transgender athletes to play women’s sports and defunding the police, putting the Democrats on the wrong side of what’s been called “80-20” issues that are overwhelmingly unpopular among most Americans. Yet they’ve won a few victories: Zohran Mamdani is the mayor of New York, and Graham Platner will be the Democratic nominee for Senate in Maine after the more moderate Gov. Janet Mills ended her primary campaign. 

How will the divide between progressives and more establishment-aligned Democrats shake out this fall? The Iowa Senate primary on June 2 will give us some clues. Michael Warren reported from rural Henry County, where progressive state Sen. Zach Walls appeared at a May Day event. Walls is running against state Rep. Josh Turek, a more pragmatic candidate who enjoys the backing of former Sen. Tom Harkin. The race promises to offer some insight on Democratic sentiments. As Mike wrote on Friday: 

If Wahls has an advantage in the primary—and sparse polling suggests it’s anybody’s race to win—it’s that he better taps into the anti-establishment mood invigorating base Democratic voters. He frequently disparages Turek as an insider and the choice of Washington insiders. That’s mainly for having the support of Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and significant financial backing (more than $5.5 million so far, according to the group) from a Schumer-affiliated super PAC, VoteVets. Wahls has insisted he will not back Schumer for leader if he is elected to the Senate, unlike Turek, who, in a televised debate with Wahls this week, declined to say whether he would support Schumer as leader. 

…

Turek’s argument is that winning is more important than ideological purity, pitching himself to Democratic primary voters as the more reliable bet to go up against Hinson. He maintains that Wahls is unelectable, especially since the two-term state senator has never run against a Republican and hails from the liberal enclave of Johnson County, which contains Iowa City and the University of Iowa.

I started out talking about redistricting, so I will close by sharing Charles Hilu’s article from Friday, looking at three Southern states that are scrambling to redraw their congressional maps after the Supreme Court struck down Louisiana’s map in Louisiana v. Callais. The court ruled that Louisiana’s existing map amounted to an unconstitutional racial gerrymander, and critics accused the court of weakening the Voting Rights Act. Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry has postponed the state’s primary, scheduled for May 16, to give the state legislature time to draw new maps. Charles explains what’s going on in Louisiana as well as Alabama and Tennessee. Check it out.

Thank you for reading. And a special thank you to everyone who offered good wishes to our son, who last weekend became a second lieutenant, college graduate, and husband. We had some wonderful family time, and I spent a good chunk of Monday napping to recover. Have a great weekend, and Happy Mother’s Day.

From the numbers-monkeys over in the statistical department comes the news that U.S. government debt has crossed a red line: Debt held by the public now exceeds 100 percent of GDP, those figures being $31.27 trillion and $31.22 trillion, respectively. What that means is that if the federal government were somehow able to pass a tax that would confiscate 100 percent of the output of the U.S. economy for a year—if consumption somehow magically fell to $0.00 and Americans were able to do nothing else with their economic efforts except put their fruits toward the national debt—it would not be enough. Oh, don’t worry—it gets worse. On top of the $31.3 trillion in federal debt per se, there’s another $88 trillion or so (some estimates are higher) in unfunded liabilities for major entitlements such as Social Security and Medicare. There’s another $1.5 trillion or so in unfunded state and local government pension liabilities, which are not a federal liability as a formal matter, but it is all the same from the taxpayers’ collective point of view, and the pressure for a federal bailout of the states may very well overwhelm our weak-kneed Congress. Call it $120 trillion in the hole just to keep the number simple. That is just a little bit more than the total economic output of the entire human race in 2025. That is a lot of money: In fact, even if you define “money” relatively broadly (here, I’m using M2, meaning all the cash, checking and savings deposits, and smaller instruments such as certificates of deposit) it is—fun fact!—more than all the money in the world. Oh, don’t worry—it gets worse.

Consider the character and background of the man. He is manifestly a man of God and a man of prayer, whose deep faith allows him to approach matters calmly, as an adult. In a world of voluble leaders, he speaks quietly. He listens carefully. As the former leader of the Order of St. Augustine—which is not unlike being the pater familias of a sometimes-fractious family—he has experience dealing with the ecclesiastical analogs to Crazy Uncle Charlie at Thanksgiving dinner, so he doesn’t get rattled. Moreover, it has been too little remarked that Pope Leo’s Villanova undergraduate degree was in mathematics and his doctorate from Rome’s Angelicum was in canon law. Which is to say that he is a man who thinks about problems and takes decisions analytically, rather than idiosyncratically (much less autocratically); he takes his time in working the equations, so to speak. His canonical background means that respect for the rule of law has been restored to Vatican governance, after a pontificate that sometimes stretched the boundaries of lawfulness to the breaking point. That, in turn, has calmed the very troubled bureaucratic and institutional waters stirred up by the volatility of Pope Francis.

I think the White House ballroom is a pretty good analog to the Iran war. Trump often says that many presidents have wanted a ballroom, but he’s the only one to do it. He’s also said that many of his predecessors wanted to deal with Iran and its nuclear program, but he’s the only one with the courage and the brains to actually do it. … In case you don’t see the comparison: Trump does something unilaterally because the gelded Congress lets him, and his biggest fans take it on faith that he knows what he’s doing. Then, when it goes sideways, he demands Congress fix it on the taxpayers’ tab. Admittedly, sometimes he unilaterally creates a mess to solve a problem, then backs down and claims he solved the problem he created. This is the essence of the TACO trade zig-zags. The Iran War is shaping up to borrow from both models. If—and I think it is a huge if—he gets the Strait of Hormuz open he will declare victory and celebrate how only he could have gotten the waterway—which was open before the war—opened. The war is a war, and it is an unauthorized—and arguably illegal—one at that. It started as a vanity project draped in national security arguments (many defensible ones in the abstract), but it will likely end as a “success” because the stock market will go up in response to him simply “ending” the war without achieving his goals. The ballroom, unauthorized and arguably illegal, started as a developer’s vanity project, but will be declared a success by turning it into a national security project.

Best of the Rest

Protesters holding signs with political messages about Zionism gather in front of the Palace of Westminster and Big Ben in London.

Anti-Zionism Is a Dead End for Palestinians

John Aziz /

The ideology prescribing the end of Israel will not lead to statehood or security.

Large black metal letters spelling "DONALD J. TRUMP" and "ORAL CENTER F" mounted on a light gray building facade with white columns.

America Needs an Edifice Complex Prevention Act

Dan Greenberg /

Public service, especially the presidency, shouldn’t be an exercise in self-glorification.

A blue-toned businessman in a suit gestures expressively against a background of stacked U.S. dollar bills, symbolizing wealth, finance, or corporate power.

The Math and the Mechanics on Kevin Warsh’s Smaller Fed

Kyla Scanlon /

What Warsh can actually do with the Fed’s $6.7 trillion.

Multiple people wait in line at numbered registration or check-in stations staffed by volunteers in a modern building with large windows overlooking trees.

In Gerrymandering Wars, Republicans and Democrats Are Both At Fault

Chris Butler /

Partisan gerrymandering hurts minority voters no matter who does it.

A man in a dark suit stands at a presidential podium making a peace sign while addressing a crowd at an inaugural ceremony on the steps of a grand neoclassical building decorated with red, white, and blue bunting.

‘Morning Again’: Reagan’s Belief in National Renewal

Fred Ryan /

The 40th president’s unshakable faith in the American people formed the foundation of his leadership.

An industrial complex with multiple tall smokestacks emitting white smoke sits along a river valley beneath a cloudy sky, with forested mountains visible in the background.

Central Planning Never Works—Even in the Energy Industry

Philip Rossetti /

Why Trump’s invocation of the Defense Production Act to boost fossil fuel production is doomed to fail.

# Alt Text A collage of French market and street scenes in orange and blue tones, featuring a café terrace, produce displays, and fresh vegetables at outdoor markets, accented with red stars.

On Being an American Expat

Thomas Dichter /

Is American identity portable?

Dispatch Podcast Generic (3392 x 1696 px)

The End of Operation Epic Fury

Trump winds down military conflict with Iran.

ADVISORY OPINIONS SITE THUMB (3392 x 1696 px)

Congress Did Something!

Sarah Isgur & David French /

All about the Voting Rights Act.

REMNANT SITE THUMB (3392 x 1696 px) (1)
Unlocked
The Remnant

Gettin’ Wonky on the Unitary Executive | Interview: Charlie Cooke

Jonah Goldberg /

Charlie’s more than just a cool accent.

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Rachael Larimore is a managing editor of The Dispatch and is based in the Cincinnati area. Prior to joining the company in 2019, she served in similar roles at Slate, The Weekly Standard, and The Bulwark. She and her husband have three sons.

Newsletter selected

Click sign up to start receiving your newsletters.

More We Think You’d Like

Newsletter selected

Click sign up to start receiving your newsletters.

Loading