Turn any article into a podcast. Upgrade now to start listening.
Members can share articles with friends & family to bypass the paywall.
Hello and happy Saturday. President Donald Trump has a history of valuing loyalty over winnability in his endorsements of primary candidates, often to the detriment of the Republican Party. (See: Herschel Walker, Mehmet Oz.) Meanwhile, Democrats have a history of getting excited about—and investing oodles of money in—buzzy candidates who want to unseat GOP incumbents in red states. (See: Beto O’Rourke, Amy McGrath.) Those trends are on a collision course in the Texas Senate race.
Trump-backed Texas state Attorney General Ken Paxton ousted incumbent Sen. John Cornyn on Tuesday in a runoff for the GOP nomination. Paxton carries a significant amount of baggage into the general election: He was impeached in 2023 by the Republican-dominated Texas Legislature over a host of allegations involving bribery, misuse of his office, false statements, and an extramarital affair, though he was acquitted. Paxton’s wife, who was a state senator at the time and recused herself from the impeachment vote, has since filed for divorce.
His Democratic opponent is James Talarico, a member of the Texas House and a Presbyterian seminary student whom Republicans have mocked for his progressive religious views—he once said “God is nonbinary” and has argued that the Bible allows for abortion. Talarico has drawn comparisons to Beto O’Rourke, the former U.S. representative who lost to Sen. Ted Cruz in 2018 despite raising $80 million from Democrats who wanted to turn Texas blue. O’Rourke did make it close—losing by only 2.6 points. Can Talarico do better? David Drucker spoke with Republican strategists in Texas who are concerned that he can. He reports:
Many Republican insiders … worry the myriad personal and professional improprieties dogging Paxton, plus Trump’s deep unpopularity with independent voters, will enable Talarico, a state senator, to overpower the strong GOP advantage in statewide elections, snapping the Democratic Party’s 30-year losing streak.
Paxton’s best defense in a November campaign that public polling shows as a toss-up? Making the Senate race a referendum on Talarico and his well-articulated liberal positions, Republican operatives in Texas told The Dispatch, gives them the most confidence among available options. “I think [it should be] all about Talarico and what a crazy lefty he is. I do,” a veteran Republican consultant in Texas said, requesting anonymity to speak candidly.
Republicans have wasted no time taking up that advice, as Nick Catoggio observed Thursday in Boiling Frogs. He points out that White House deputy chief of staff Stephen Miller has called Talarico “the first transgender Senate candidate” nominated by Democrats and that conservative media personalities have insinuated that Talarico is gay. Nick argues that the strategy allows Republicans to ignore the actual issues that are dominating the midterm conversations—issues that the president’s policies have exacerbated. He writes:
The point of calling Talarico a gay vegan pagan isn’t to win over swing voters. It’s to persuade the Cornyn conservatives I wrote about yesterday to swallow their contempt for Paxton and show up for him in November. The GOP has the numbers to win in Texas; all it needs to do is turn out its base. “You’re not going to let a queer represent cowboy country, are you?” is more likely to do that than debating Talarico on affordability would.
Republicans couldn’t engage on that point even if they wanted to. What could they say after tariffs, a needless oil-supply disaster in the Strait of Hormuz, and Trump signaling at every opportunity that he doesn’t give a flip how much Americans suffer for his agenda? A campaign fought over the cost of living is one Talarico can win. A campaign that amounts to little more than “transvestigating” him is not.
The Morning Dispatch on Thursday looked at Trump’s influence over the broader election cycle. The party that controls the White House typically suffers setbacks in the midterms. Trump’s low approval ratings, voter pessimism about the economy, and fallout from the Iran war are only adding to the GOP’s challenge. While Talarico’s campaign could end up being a repeat of O’Rourke’s, Paxton’s scandal-ridden record still creates problems for Republicans. “One of the biggest problems [for Republicans here] isn’t necessarily that Ken Paxton is definitely going to lose this race,” Carrie Dann, managing editor of Cook Political Report, told TMD. “But they will have to spend hundreds of millions of dollars after already just throwing $100 million to try to save John Cornyn.”
When Drucker spoke to Republican operatives before the Paxton-Cornyn runoff, sources told them that officials with the National Republican Senatorial Committee and the Senate Leadership Fund, two groups that work to elect Republicans to the Senate and who had backed Cornyn over Paxton, would not be inclined to support Paxton were he to win. How’s that going? As TMD reported on Thursday:
By Wednesday, the National Republican Senatorial Committee had begun deleting the press releases, social media posts, and ads it once aimed at Paxton, among them statements branding his treatment of his wife “truly repulsive and disgusting.”
Thank you for reading. Before you go, be sure to check out Charles Hilu’s special feature on the strange bedfellows working together to fight assisted suicide in Connecticut, the latest installment in our Next 250 series on the history of homeschooling, and Jonah Goldberg’s G-File on “superstitious learning.” Have a great weekend!
Assisted suicide has been a divisive topic in the United States and other countries for decades. In states where it is legal, patients may request a prescription from a doctor for drugs they can ingest to end their own lives. In 2025, New York, Delaware, and Illinois became the latest states to legalize it. But the issue has always brought together people of different political stripes in opposition. Religious social conservatives who emphasize the inherent dignity of human life will oppose it, and so will disability rights advocates and progressives who worry that its legalization could exploit marginalized people. When the New York State Assembly passed its assisted suicide bill last year, approximately 20 Democrats voted against it, while Republicans were unanimously opposed. “I cannot support legislation that legalizes medical aid in dying because our healthcare system is deeply inequitable and profit-driven,” Assemblymember Michaelle Solages—who chairs the legislature’s Black, Puerto Rican, Hispanic and Asian Legislative Caucus—said. “In a system where too many are denied basic care because of cost, race, disability, or poverty, introducing assisted death risks creating pressure on the most vulnerable to choose death over life.” It’s not uncommon for people of different political persuasions to disagree with legalizing assisted suicide, but it’s more unusual for them to actively work together to stop it. Yet that’s what opponents in Connecticut who reside along different points of the ideological spectrum have done.
Abigail Adams offers an excellent example of how American society once envisioned education. Born to a well-to-do Massachusetts clergyman in 1744, Adams was frustrated not to receive formal schooling. She saw many boys go off to excellent schools, and while she was better-placed socioeconomically to attend such a school than many girls were, she was denied that chance due to her parents’ anxieties and contemporary social reticence about extended schooling for females, according to historian Woody Holton’s biography of Adams. Yet, as Holton demonstrates, she was also well equipped to self-educate because her contemporary culture supported this form of education; for centuries in America, it was common for young people to study under the tutelage of older relatives (like Adams’ grandmother) or to share books and letters with peers. This form of self-improvement was not merely moral, but truly about growing in critical thinking, self-expression, reading fluency, and knowledge. Adams even taught herself French this way. Not everyone who did not attend school in this era—and even some who did—learned as well or as much as Adams, and girls usually received less academic education than boys, but those young people who could study in this way could enjoy a real, rich, and formative education. Even less well-off children like the future navigator Nathaniel Bowditch or the ill-used printer’s apprentice Benjamin Franklin—each of whom received only a little schooling—could achieve a good academic education, if they could get enough books and leisure time to pursue it.
Superstitious learning is a term applied to CEOs who shepherd a merger at the beginning of an economic boom and conclude that their surging profits are the result of the merger, so they double down on the strategy. The voters who thought they’d be getting the pre-COVID economy of Donald Trump’s first term made the same error, thinking the president wills a good economy into existence. K Street is full of self-styled rainmakers who got rich by dancing when the first droplet hit the pavement so they could take credit for the downpour. By the way, the term “superstitious learning” is rooted in the work of B.F. Skinner, who used the word “superstition” to describe how pigeons that bobbed their head before a pellet appeared assumed that the pellet resulted from their head bob. I’ve long argued that such biases are key to understanding Trump. He’s the millionth monkey banging on a typewriter, or perhaps the one throwing darts at the stock pages. He ignores valuable and important rules and when things work out for him, he thinks the rules are B.S. His narcissism transmogrifies failure as the downpayment on success, and you can’t wholly blame him for it. But one proof that he’s an exception that proves the rule is that superstitious learners who imitate him tend to fail (unless he pardons them).
Best of the Rest
A Quagmire of Trump’s Own Making
The president who sold his leadership as a unitary executive seems frustrated by the results of trying to fight a war that way.
Iran’s New ‘Nuclear’ Weapon
What happens if the U.S. declines to fight for the Strait of Hormuz.
How New Interceptors Are Transforming Drone Warfare in Ukraine
Air defense units are using small guided rockets to take out Russia’s Shahed drones.
The World’s Oldest Hatred Surfaces in the San Diego Mosque Shooting
All Semitic people should recognize the scourge of hateful ideology.
Is Bill Cassidy’s Loss a MAHA Win?
What his primary defeat means for federal health agencies and MAHA’s influence in the administration.
SCOTUS Through the Decades | Interview: Nina Totenberg
Plus: IQ tests and the death penalty.
Can Humanity Be Protected from Artificial Intelligence?
On Pope Leo’s AI warning.
Why Postliberalism Failed | Interview: James M. Patterson and Thomas D. Howes
Postliberal vivisection.
Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?
Add Us as a Preferred Source














