Skip to content
Four vintage microphones form columns supporting a detailed classical pediment against a solid red background, combining media and architecture themes.

SCOTUS Through the Decades | Interview: Nina Totenberg

Sarah Isgur & David French /
Listen on your player of choice

Sarah Isgur and David French discuss an anticlimactic dig from the Supreme Court over IQ tests and the death penalty and challenges to the $1.8 billion slush fund President Donald Trump created on weaponization, and they talk with NPR's Nina Totenberg about covering the Supreme Court.

The Agenda:

—How many IQ tests does a person on death row need to take?

—Who can challenge the slush fund?

—James Comey as the platonic ideal plaintiff

—The embarrassing DNC autopsy, and Grifter Sarah makes an appearance

—Interview with Nina Totenberg 

Order Sarah’s book here.

Advisory Opinions is a production of SCOTUSblog and The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a nonpartisan perspective. Click here to sign up for our new Advisory Opinions newsletter, and click here to access all of The Dispatch’s offerings, including audio versions of all our articles and newsletters. If you’d like to remove all ads from your podcast experience, consider becoming a premium Dispatch member by clicking here.

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Sarah Isgur is a senior editor at The Dispatch and is based in Texas. Prior to joining the company in 2019, she had worked in every branch of the federal government and on three presidential campaigns. She’s also an ABC News contributor and the New York Times bestselling author of Last Branch Standing, a deep dive into the inner workings of the Supreme Court. When Sarah is not hosting podcasts or writing newsletters, she’s probably sending uplifting stories about spiders to Jonah, who only pretends to love all animals.

David French is a columnist for the New York Times. He’s a former senior editor of The Dispatch. He’s the author most recently of Divided We Fall: America's Secession Threat and How to Restore Our Nation.

The podcast transcription below was generated using artificial intelligence and may include occasional errors or misspellings.

Music

Ready?

Music

I was born ready.

Music

[upbeat music]

Sarah Isgur

Welcome to Advisory Opinions. I'm Sarah Isgur, that's David French, and today we do have an opinion from the Supreme Court. Well, wait, no, we have an outcome from the Supreme Court, Ham v. Smith, death penalty and IQ. How many IQ tests do you need to take to be ineligible for the death penalty, and what do those scores need to be? And how many times does the case need to be relisted before we actually get a decision? And speaking of court cases, what's a girl gotta do to get into court to challenge the one point eight billion dollar slush fund that Donald Trump has created on weaponization? More on that. And lastly, David, an interview with the OG, man, Nina Totenberg from NPR. She has covered the Supreme Court for nearly 50 years, and I spoke with her a couple days ago without David, and you'll get to hear all of that right here on Advisory Opinions. Well, David, we got one decision from the Supreme Court that is worth at least a few moments of our time. This was Ham versus Smith. This case has been around for two decades at this point. It holds the record for relists at the Supreme Court in history. It was relisted 23 times in its former iteration. To explain what that means to people who are not relist watch subscribers with Jon Elwood, though you should be on SCOTUSblog because that's the most fun game in town. When the Court considers a petition at conference, their choices are to deny cert, the much more likely outcome, grant cert, not that likely an outcome, or to hold it over till the next conference. That's called relisting it. And in fact, most of the cert grants have been relisted once or twice. What's unusual is for it to be relisted as in held over conference to conference for 23 conferences in a row. By the way, like Jon Elwood has done the work here and shown that relisting once or twice raises your chances of a cert grant enormously. But too many cert, uh, relists actually has diminishing returns, and your chance of a cert grant then starts going down precipitously. So once Ham was in the teens-- I mean, heck, once Ham was in the double digits, the chances of that being granted cert were relatively low. So what happened? Well, in that case, they just sent it back to the Eleventh Circuit. The Eleventh Circuit decided it again, and then it came back again to the Supreme Court. This time they granted cert. So what's the case about? Well, Ham has been sitting on death row for two decades, and the argument from his counsel was that he was intellectually disabled and therefore ineligible for the death penalty. And he had taken five IQ scores. He had scored ranging from 72 to 78,

Sarah Isgur

and the question was whether his IQ was 70 or lower. But the margin of error is about three points, so that 72 IQ score with the margin of error included would put him at 69, which would put him below 70. And if you're wondering where in the Eighth Amendment anyone got this, well, uh, several things, David.

Interactive transcripts are available to Premium members. Join to follow along with the audio.

Join Now

More We Think You’d Like

Loading