Skip to content
A paper boat made from newspaper floats on a light blue background, casting a subtle shadow. The tone is whimsical, blending creativity with media concepts.

Blame the Girlboss?

Victoria Holmes talks with Patrick T. Brown, a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center, about the rise and fall of girl-boss feminism, the birth rate collapse, and whether a new generation is returning to a "traditional" lifestyle.

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Victoria Holmes is a multimedia producer at The Dispatch and is based in Washington, D.C. Prior to joining the company in 2022, she worked as a TV news reporter and podcast host. When she's not producing and editing podcasts and multimedia content, she enjoys discovering new restaurant spots or planning her next escape to the beach.

The podcast transcription below was generated using artificial intelligence and may include occasional errors or misspellings.

Victoria Holmes

Who Will Speak for the Girl Boss? is an article written by Patrick T. Brown, a fellow at the Ethics and Public Policy Center. The article pushes back against conservative and far-right commentators blaming feminism for the decline in fertility rates. Patrick joins me to discuss the factors behind the birth rate collapse, how COVID impacted families, and whether or not a new generation is returning to religion and family. How would you define girl boss feminism?

Patrick T. Brown

Oh, [sighs] there's so many definitions, and in, in some respect, this whole conversation just goes to show how frustrating it can be to try to come up with any sort of workable definition. I think, you know, in the Sheryl Sandberg era, the sort of lean in conversation back in the early twenty tens, it was all about, you know, going for the corporate, uh, ladder, looking for that corner office, big promotion. You know, that was kind of the girl boss version one point O. I think in more recent years, we've seen it used almost sort of more ironically or, or, or more casually to refer to anything from just a woman who happens to be working or, or the sort of Gen Z boss with the many videos that go viral online to, you know, a mom selling LuLaRoe leggings out of her basement. I, I, I think we've kind of lost, you know, any conceptual clarity that that label ended, ever ended up having in the first place. And so to me, it's worth taking a step back and going, "Okay, what are we actually looking at here when we look at declining fertility in America?" Especially since two thousand seven, which is when we kind of hit peak baby, uh, it's been all downhill since then. And I think the kind of people who are saying, "Well, it's all feminism's fault, it's all girl boss's fault. It's because women are working and they're not, you know, barefoot and pregnant in the kitchen anymore," that's just misunderstanding the dynamics of what's actually going on, in my opinion.

Victoria Holmes

So what do you mean by peak baby?

Patrick T. Brown

Yeah. So A- American fertility, just like everywhere else across the globe, has been in decline, you know, pretty steadily since the mid two thousands. Uh, two thousand and seven was the most babies born on record in the U.S. It was about four point three million babies. We're down to about three point six million now. And again, this isn't unique to us. South Korea, Japan, Asia in general, Europe, pretty much everywhere outside of sub-Saharan Africa, been a lot of conversation about this, has been seeing a decline in births. And so people go, "Okay, so what is the culprit here?" One that I think continues to be kind of under-remarked upon is just how much of it is downstream from a decline in marriage. Here in the U.S., it's about, you know, roughly, I would say probably three-quarters of the decline in births since two thousand seven can be directly attributed to a decline in marriage, people not getting married and also the marriage rate among non-married women going down considerably. For conservatives, this is actually somewhat of a victory. I mean, you think about, you know, sort of Rick Santorum and Daniel Moynihan and all these sort of g- you know, uh, ink that was spilled over rising non-marital births for the last part of the twentieth century. We've seen that trend dramatically reverse. The problem is people aren't going on to marry and have kids. They're just not getting married at all, and that's the biggest driver of, of declining fertility in the U.S.

Victoria Holmes

I wanna go back to two thousand seven when we were at peak baby boom. What factors led to that? And then can we recreate those factors today?

Interactive transcripts are available to Premium members. Join to follow along with the audio.

Join Now

More We Think You’d Like

Loading