Members can share articles with friends & family to bypass the paywall.
Steve Hayes is joined by Kevin Williamson, Mike Warren, and Mike Nelson to discuss rising tensions between the U.S. and Iran in the Strait of Hormuz and the disconnect between the White House’s words and actions.
The Agenda:
—Attacks in the Strait of Hormuz
—Who can keep the Strait open
—Project Freedom
—Trump’s rising political pressure
—Democrats’ midterm messaging
—NWYT: Philadelphia 76ers ban New York Knicks fans
Dispatch Recommendations:
—A Pope You Don’t Have To Think About Every Day
—Is There a China Strategy Behind the Iran War?
—Liebling at War
—All the Money in the World, and Then Some
Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?
Add Us as a Preferred SourceThe podcast transcription below was generated using artificial intelligence and may include occasional errors or misspellings.
[upbeat music] Welcome to the Dispatch podcast. I'm Steve Hayes. On today's roundtable, we'll return to the Iran war and discuss the ever-changing rhetoric from the Trump administration. Is the war effectively over, or should we settle in for something longer, as President Trump recently suggested, invoking Vietnam for context? We'll also discuss the state of the negotiations with Iran and the Trump administration's attempt to extend the sixty-day congressional authorization window requirements of the War Powers Act. And finally, not worth your time, the Philadelphia Seventy-Sixers restricting access to Knicks fans? I'm joined today by my Dispatch colleagues Kevin Williamson, Mike Warren, and Dispatch contributor Mike Nelson. Let's dive right in. [upbeat music] Hey, everybody, just a quick update before we jump into the recording. We recorded Monday morning from nine thirty to ten thirty, and in the hours after the recording, there was some additional activity. There were reports of Iranian strikes on the UAE, and Admiral Brad Cooper of CENTCOM told reporters that Iran had opened fire on U.S. warships and commercial vessels today. So that is not reflected in our conversation here, but the main contours of the conversation remain the same.
Morning, gentlemen. Welcome. We're recording this at about nine thirty on Monday, May fourth, and there's news this morning out of the Strait of Hormuz. Iranian state media claim that an American warship was struck by two missiles after the crew ignored warnings about entry into the strait. The United States, however, says no U.S. warships were struck. The White House has rejected another proposed peace deal from Iran, and following reports that this weekend that President Trump is getting antsy. He's sour about the lack of diplomatic progress, frustrated by the continued blockage of the strait, concerned about slipping domestic U.S. support. The president put a statement out on social media Sunday afternoon telling the world that the U.S. will begin helping ships unable to traverse the strait as a, quote, "humanitarian gesture,"
warning the regime that it best not interfere. Mike Nelson, you've got a piece up this morning, and I want to go further into depth on your piece and your argument a little bit later. But just off the news of the past eighteen, twenty-four hours, it feels to me like we are potentially sort of in the proverbial calm before the storm. Am I right about that?
Well, I don't know if we're in the calm before the storm or if we're in the be-- in, in the outer rings of the storm itself, but what we're seeing, I think, is a disconnect between what the president and the White House are overtly trying to present and what the Iranians are communicating back in their actions. Within the last twelve or twenty-four hours, we had the announcement of Project Freedom, which seems to be euphemistically named. It sounded originally like a military operation to try to escort ships through the strait. Number one, it's probably not named that because we've just declared or attested to Congress that the war is over to try to skirt the War Powers timelines. In clarifying it, some of the administration and the DoD officials have said it's-- no, it's more of a coordination cell that, that communicates to international shipping when and where things are clear. Since then, we've had two incidents now. We had international ship, the UK maritime trackers, a reporting called the Minnow and Falcon, ironic on Star Wars Day, that could not run a, a blockade and may have been struck by an Iranian missile. And then we have the Iranian claims of having struck a U.S. warship, which CENTCOM has denied. We saw something similar in the past when there was an attack on one of our CSGs that was defeated by the U.S. Navy, but that CENTCOM had not disclosed for some period of time. So there may be somewhere in between where the Iranians have attacked a U.S. warship, but the attack was unsuccessful. Regardless, it shows that they are not taking seriously our communication that the strait is going to be open, that they had better not interfere. They are sticking by their initial communication that the strait is closed, and it will remain closed until the U.S. agrees to withdraw our blockade, one of their preconditions that they've demanded as part of their fourteen-point plan that, as you mentioned, was at least in part rejected by the White House.
Kevin, you wrote last week that the Trump administration's failure to keep the strait open was a sign of weakness. You wrote, "The Strait of Hormuz is an international waterway under maritime law, but the Trump administration insists on treating the strait as though it were sovereign Iranian territory, doing so for reasons ranging from incompetence to political cowardice." What would you have the administration do, given that this is an international waterway?
Interactive transcripts are available to Premium members. Join to follow along with the audio.
Join Now



