Skip to content
Dark blue background with "The Dispatch Podcast" written in red and white serif font. The tone is professional and polished.

Can the U.S. Tax Code Be Simplified?

Listen on your player of choice

Steve Hayes is joined by Mike Warren, Scott Lincicome, and Megan McArdle to discuss our overly complicated tax code and our launch of Dispatch Markets, featuring Scott's latest newsletter. Steve, Megan, and Mike then discuss New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani's pied-à-terre tax and how the democratic socialist mayor has governed so far.

The Agenda:
—Donald Rumsfeld's tax letter
—The cost of tax compliance
—Political will for tax reform
—Personal vs. corporate tax complexity
—Mamdani's pied-à-terre tax
—Economic policy in New York
—NWYT: J.D. Vance's small crowd

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Steve Hayes is CEO and editor of The Dispatch, based in Annapolis, Maryland. Prior to co-founding the company in 2019, he worked at The Weekly Standard for 18 years, covering Washington, politics, and national security. Steve is the author of two New York Times bestsellers. He also worked as a contributor at CNN and Fox News, and currently serves as a political analyst at NBC News. When Steve is not focused on The Dispatch, he’s probably traveling with his family, grilling, or riding his mountain bike.

Megan McArdle is a Washington Post columnist, host of the Reasonably Optimistic podcast, and the author of The Up Side of Down: Why Failing Well Is the Key to Success.

Michael Warren is politics editor at The Dispatch and is based in Washington, D.C. A former on-air reporter at CNN and a senior writer at The Weekly Standard, he has spent more than 15 years covering lawmakers on Capitol Hill, the White House and the executive branch, the conservative movement, and political campaigns. When Mike is not reporting, writing, editing, and podcasting, he is probably spending time with his wife and three sons.

Scott Lincicome is an author of the Dispatch Markets newsletter, vice president of general economics and trade at the Cato Institute, and a visiting lecturer at Duke University Law School. He wrote the Capitolism newsletter at The Dispatch from 2020 through 2026.

The podcast transcription below was generated using artificial intelligence and may include occasional errors or misspellings.

Steve Hayes

[upbeat music] Welcome to the Dispatch Podcast. I'm Steve Hayes, and I want to start today with some very exciting news. We at The Dispatch are very pleased to announce the launch of Dispatch Markets in partnership with the US Chamber of Commerce. This project will explore US capitalism and economic policy at a time when free enterprise is no longer the assumption and the backdrop. It's increasingly the argument front and center, and often under attack from both the progressive left and the populist right. Expect topics to range from how the Trump administration's tariffs are rippling through the economy to the challenges facing the Federal Reserve System, from AI and the future of work to tax policy. The authors will bring the intellectual honesty, respect for economic realities, and a willingness to grapple with trade-offs that we hope have become a hallmark of The Dispatch. The roster is impressive, and we're very excited about it. Contributors will include Scott Lincicome, Vice President of Economics at the Cato Institute, lecturer at Duke University Law School, and author of the Capitalism Newsletter here at The Dispatch since twenty-twenty. Megan McArdle, a Dispatch contributor and Washington Post columnist, host of the Reasonably Optimistic podcast, and author of The Upside of Down. Carl Smith, a senior fellow at the Center for Strategic and International Studies and former Bloomberg columnist, uh, longtime vice president at the Tax Foundation. Kyla Scanlon, author of a widely read Substack and In This Economy, as well as a Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator fellow and New York Times contributor. Marian Tupy, founder of humanprogress.org, co-author of Superabundance, and a senior fellow at the Cato Institute. And today, I'm joined by two authors of Dispatch Markets, Scott Lincicome and Megan McArdle, as well as by Dispatch senior editor Mike Warren. We'll discuss Scott's just-published newsletter on our overly complicated tax code and the political right fight over how to reform it. We'll also discuss New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani's proposed tax on second homes within the city worth five million dollars or more. And finally, for Not Worth Your Time, a small crowd for Vice President J.D. Vance. Let's dive in. [upbeat music]

Steve Hayes

Hey, everybody. Thanks for joining. I want to start with a letter that Donald Rumsfeld used to send to the IRS every Tax Day. The former defense secretary wrote, "I have sent in our federal income tax and our gift tax returns for fill in the year. As in prior years, it's important for you to know that I have absolutely no idea whether our tax returns and our tax payments are accurate." Rumsfeld goes on, "The tax code is so complex and the forms are so complicated that I know I cannot have any confidence that I know what's being requested, and therefore I cannot and do not know, and I suspect a great many Americans cannot know, whether or not their tax returns are accurate."

Steve Hayes

Scott, you have a terrific newsletter out Friday, the inaugural issue of the Dispatch Markets vertical, and you went very deep on tax complexity and reminded me actually of the Donald Rumsfeld letter. What's the problem here?

Scott Lincicome

[laughs] Well, the problem on its face is just simply that the tax code keeps getting more and more complex, and that forces all of us, including me and probably a lot of other people listening, to spend countless springtime weekends toiling away in our home offices trying to find receipts and PDFs and things that were mailed to us by random universities that had you out to speak and so on and so on to simply send the government another check. A very frustrating process. So that's, on its face, it's just, it keeps getting more complicated. But buried beneath that is the reality that Congress loves handing out goodies or punishing folks via the tax code. And there has been an explosion in what are called tax expenditures. This is just ways to give y-- this person a credit or that energy supply a credit and on and on, deductions and on. And the taxes are the easiest way to do that for lots of boring political reasons that maybe Mike can get, get into. And thus, almost every year now, m-- every other year surely, there's another tax thing that's added to the code, and it just keeps getting longer and longer.

Steve Hayes

So you have some examples of just how long the code is and just how much time people spend on it. I'm just gonna read a little bit from your piece talking about how much Americans spend on their taxes. Five hundred and thirty-six billion in twenty twenty-four, twenty twenty-five, one point seven percent of twenty twenty-five gross domestic product. These are numbers according to our friends at the Tax Foundation. And Scott, you write, "To put these figures in context, five hundred and thirty-six billion is more than the corporate income tax will generate this year, around twice as much as Trump's tariffs will raise, and more than forty-three times the IRS budget. The seven point one billion hours spent complying, meanwhile, is the equivalent to three point four million full-time American workers, almost the population of Los Angeles, doing nothing but tax paperwork for a full year."

Interactive transcripts are available to Premium members. Join to follow along with the audio.

Join Now

More We Think You’d Like

Loading