Skip to content
Dark blue background with "The Dispatch Podcast" written in red and white serif font. The tone is professional and polished.

Can the State Be Trusted With the Death Penalty?

Listen on your player of choice

Steve Hayes is joined by Jonah Goldberg, Mike Warren, and John McCormack to discuss the botched execution of convicted murderer Christa Pike and Angela Paxton’s “endorsement” ad for Senate candidate Ken Paxton, her estranged husband.

The Agenda:

—Catholic arguments against the death penalty

—What should the state do now?

—Iowa Senate race

—Candidate selection matters

—NWYT: Bowling

Show notes:

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Steve Hayes is CEO and editor of The Dispatch, based in Annapolis, Maryland. Prior to co-founding the company in 2019, he worked at The Weekly Standard for 18 years, covering Washington, politics, and national security. Steve is the author of two New York Times bestsellers. He also worked as a contributor at CNN and Fox News, and currently serves as a political analyst at NBC News. When Steve is not focused on The Dispatch, he’s probably traveling with his family, grilling, or riding his mountain bike.

Jonah Goldberg is editor-in-chief and co-founder of The Dispatch, based in Washington, D.C. Prior to that, enormous lizards roamed the Earth. More immediately prior to that, Jonah spent two decades at National Review, where he was a senior editor, among other things. He is also a bestselling author, longtime columnist for the Los Angeles Times, commentator for CNN, and a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. When he is not writing the G-File or hosting The Remnant podcast, he finds real joy in family time, attending to his dogs and cat, and blaming Steve Hayes for various things.

Michael Warren is politics editor at The Dispatch and is based in Washington, D.C. A former on-air reporter at CNN and a senior writer at The Weekly Standard, he has spent more than 15 years covering lawmakers on Capitol Hill, the White House and the executive branch, the conservative movement, and political campaigns. When Mike is not reporting, writing, editing, and podcasting, he is probably spending time with his wife and three sons.

John McCormack is a senior editor at The Dispatch and is based in Washington, D.C. Prior to joining the company in 2023, he was Washington correspondent at National Review and a senior writer at The Weekly Standard. When John is not reporting on politics and policy, he is probably enjoying life with his wife and daughters in northern Virginia or having fun visiting family in Wisconsin.

The podcast transcription below was generated using artificial intelligence and may include occasional errors or misspellings.

Steve Hayes

[intro music playing] Welcome to the Dispatch Podcast. I'm your host, Steve Hayes. On today's roundtable, we'll look at the case of Krista Pike, a Tennessee woman convicted of murder in 1995, and her botched execution by the state last week. Can the state be trusted with the death penalty? Does this case prove the anti-death penalty crowd has been making the right argument all along? Then a New York Times/Siena poll shows that Republicans continue to fall behind Democrats. We'll talk about the competitive Senate race in Iowa with two Dispatch reporters who have spent time on the ground reporting from there, and we'll look at some telling developments in the Texas Senate race, including perhaps the most illustrative example of partisan brain rot we've seen this cycle. And then, not worth your time, bowling? I'm joined today by Dispatch Editor-in-Chief Jonah Goldberg, Politics Editor Mike Warren, and Senior Editor John McCormick. Let's dive right in. [instrumental music playing] Hello, gentlemen. Thank you for joining me. I wanna start today with a story that's been in the news over the past week, and it involves this botched execution in Tennessee, execution of a fifty-year-old woman named Krista Pike, who'd been convicted of a really gruesome murder of an acquaintance of hers from college, as I understand it. There was some kind of a love triangle. The details of the crime we will skip over, but it was a very gruesome murder. Fast-forward to this past year, Krista Pike was scheduled to be put to death. She exhausted her appeals, and the State of Tennessee attempted to execute her last week. It did not work. It did not take. And this has, I think, triggered a, a big debate nationally about the death penalty, about how to execute people if we agree that the state is going to execute them. So I wanna spend a few minutes talking about this story. And Mike, let me start with you.

Steve Hayes

I think the first question, certainly the first question that I had and the first question that people have had when I've talked to them about this over the past several days is, how is it possible to botch an execution?

Mike Warren

I think a good question. It's the first question to ask. This is a s- a responsibility that the State of Tennessee has taken on itself, and it's screwed it up royally. There's a lot to be said for the sort of bush league approach that these executions have taken now with lethal injections, where you're, you're really not getting the highest quality of pharmacists and folks who put these drugs together. And so there's a lot of guessing that goes along with it. Pieces of the sort of the cocktail, the drug cocktail that the executioners put together coming from different pharmacies. And it's ultimately, I think, just kind of shoddy work all around. And look, I say this as somebody who used to be pro-death penalty. My views on this have changed. I'm, I'm against it now. But I do believe that if a state is going to adopt the death penalty as a punishment, as the final punishment for the most heinous of crimes, they should do it right. And the fact that Tennessee was unable to do it, I think is sort of an institutional failure. And perhaps it raises some good questions for the country to ask, is this a good practice to be doing death penalties at all, to be doing state-led executions at all? But again, at the very least, there's some pretty good evidence here that lethal injections can work if they are done with the right drugs and, uh, if they are done at the highest standards of the approach to this. The problem is, is that I think these states have cheapened things out. I think Jonah's actually talked about this recently, the sort of the pressure from anti-death penalty groups to sort of put all kinds of pressure on the execution, so to speak, of these lethal injections has worsened them as well and has made it so that what you end up having here happen is this woman is now in a coma, and the state is in a bind because they-- now they can't execute her. I think there's a strong legal argument that she is no longer in a state, you know, essentially, we don't execute people who are in vegetative states, who are in comas, who are not mentally able to understand what is happening to them. And the truth is, is that this botched execution has rendered her, at the moment at least, and certainly her lawyers are arguing this, has rendered her unable to understand what is going on around her. And so not only was this botched, but it looks like at the e-end of the day, Tennessee is not going to be able to fulfill this obligation that they claimed they were able to do. So it's, it's just a real screw-up all the way around.

Steve Hayes

Yeah, it's, uh, John, it's hard to believe when you listen to Mike's answer there, the first part of his answer, that the State of Tennessee would not have taken the appropriate steps or had people who were not qualified or had the wrong mix of drugs. I mean, if you're ever gonna do anything correctly, if you're ever gonna take the extra steps to make sure you have qualified people in positions to do this the right way, you would think it would be in the context of the state putting an individual to death. And yet, I think Mike is right. A lot of the reporting has suggested that there were questions about the qualifications of people, that the mix may not have been quite right. I had listened to an interview with a professor at Emory University who is a consultant for Krista Pike's defense team, so certainly an interested- Party who was asked about what it means to be qualified to conduct such, such an execution. And he said, "Well, it's one thing to be qualified sort of on paper. It's another thing to be actually qualified." And he suggested that the state has difficulty getting people who are really qualified and know this stuff as well to do it. To Mike's point, there have been other examples of botched executions in the past. Should this be as easy to fix, problem to fix as it would seem, I think, if you're just coming to this issue cold?

John McCormack

Yeah, I mean, leaving aside my own complicated, somewhat complicated views on the death penalty, I think the problem here is with lethal injection, this attempt to sanitize and medicalize something like an execution, and that there is an instantaneous and surefire way to execute someone that is more humane than this, which is a firing squad. Honestly, I, I don't mean this to be provocative or trolling or anything. I think if you're going to... if the states wants to kill someone, we know of a one hundred percent effective way to do it that happens instantaneously. And I, I can't imagine anyone who would look at the details of this or other botched lethal injections with the pain that can be torturous or, or the failed attempts and just not think that, why don't they just do something that would actually work and be more humane than this?

Interactive transcripts are available to Premium members. Join to follow along with the audio.

Join Now

More We Think You’d Like

Loading