Members can share articles with friends & family to bypass the paywall.
Will the Supreme Court overturn religious precedent in the case of a Catholic preschool challenging its exclusion from a Colorado “universal preschool” program? Should the Supreme Court care about its own popularirty? And, is Ted Cruz a great option as for Supreme Court justice? Sarah Isgur and David French answer these questions and more, live at the University of Denver.
Also: We are launching a SCOTUSblog newsletter on April 28!
The Agenda:
–‘Universal’ pre-K causes court to re-re-reconsider major religious precedent
–This already happened
–Public Opinion, Credible Threats, and the Fezzik Principle
–Watch The Princess Bride
–Justice Ted Cruz?
–The Shadow Docket reporting by the New York Times
–Questions from the audience
Order Sarah’s book here.
Advisory Opinions is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including access to all of our articles, members-only newsletters, and bonus podcast episodes—click here. If you’d like to remove all ads from your podcast experience, consider becoming a premium Dispatch member by clicking here.
Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?
Add Us as a Preferred SourceThe podcast transcription below was generated using artificial intelligence and may include occasional errors or misspellings.
You ready?
I was born ready.
[upbeat music] Welcome to the Advisory Opinions podcast. I'm Sarah Isgur, that's David French, and we are live at the University of Denver, DU. Hey, guys. [audience cheering] [audience applauding] Well, we've got plenty to talk about today. A cert grant from the Court, another religious liberty case, David is hot to trot. Also, the Fezek principle, should the Supreme Court care if it's popular? And is Ted Cruz a great option for the Supreme Court? It's gonna be a more interesting conversation than you think. Uh, and lastly, what's the best major if you want to go to law school? Seemed appropriate to do at this campus. Okay, I do want to announce that we will have an Advisory Opinions newsletter starting on April 28th. This will include video, transcript, a summary of everything we talk about, you know, those little chapter headings where you can get just to the topic you want to find. You can sign up on SCOTUSblog starting today to sign up for the Advisory Opinions newsletter. We'll see you out there April 28th. And now, let's do some advisory opinions. David, let's start with the cert grant. I will now read to you from John Elwood at SCOTUSblog, who predicted this cert grant after several relists. "Two Catholic parish preschools, alike in... " No, just kidding, that's from Romeo and Juliet. "Two Catholic parish preschools in the Denver area," Denver, how appropriate, "and the Archdiocese of Denver challenge Colorado's universal preschool program, which offers free, publicly funded preschool to four-year-old Coloradans through a mixed delivery system that includes both public and private providers, including religious ones. The catch? To participate and receive public funding, all providers must ensure that children have an equal opportunity to enroll and receive services regardless of their or their parents' sexual orientation, gender identity, religious affiliation, race, ethnicity, disability, lack of housing, or income level. The Catholic preschools sought an exemption to allow them to turn away children of LGBT parents or children who do not conform to the church's teaching on gender on the grounds that admitting such children would require them to violate their religious convictions. When Colorado's Department of Early Childhood denied that request, they sued. The district court ruled for Colorado, finding the state's conditions to be neutral and generally applicable. The US Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed." Um, but David, as one Twitterati said, "Attorney: 'May it please the Court, this case arises out of a challenge to Colorado law.' Chief Justice Roberts: 'Thank you, counsel. Duly noted. Please proceed to your second argument.' [chuckles]" Uh, David, we have just seen so many of these Colorado laws on these exact issues in all the different contexts, be they bakers or candlestick makers, challenged, and here we are with a preschool challenge. I did wanna note something that was interesting in the cert petition [lip smacks] that is actually disputed a little bit, at least, by the two parties, uh, from the preschools suing. "Colorado nonetheless permits numerous exemptions from their non-discrimination requirement, both categorical and discretionary, allowing preschools to admit only children of color, only gender non-conforming children, and only the LGBTQ community, only low-income families, and only children with disabilities. But Colorado excludes Catholic preschools because they admit only families who support Catholic beliefs, including on sex and gender." Now, again, the state disputes this somewhat, but this is based on testimony from one of their employees who they know is not a lawyer and maybe didn't know what she was saying, something, something, something. But to me, that's the ballgame. If you can have a preschool that only has
students of color, I mean, that's obviously... That's not even a First Amendment violation. That's an equal protection violation.
Yeah. We're... By the way, we're passing the microphone back and forth. I think this is an emergency measure by Sarah to prevent me from interrupting.
Interactive transcripts are available to Premium members. Join to follow along with the audio.
Join Now



