Skip to content
Four vintage microphones form columns supporting a detailed classical pediment against a solid red background, combining media and architecture themes.

Let’s Sue the Government

Sarah Isgur & David French /
Listen on your player of choice

Sarah Isgur and David French discuss the IRS lawsuit brought by President Donald Trump, SCOTUS’s mifepristone decision, and a unanimous verdict from the justices that no one except Sarah cares about. 

The Agenda:

–The Bivens brick wall

–Trump loses on the law but wins in the politics

–Ballroom and baby steps

–Brief explainer on the Comstock Act

Show Notes:

Advisory Opinions is a production of SCOTUSblog and The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a nonpartisan perspective. Click here to sign up for our new Advisory Opinions newsletter, and click here to access all of The Dispatch’s offerings, including audio versions of all our articles and newsletters. If you’d like to remove all ads from your podcast experience, consider becoming a premium Dispatch member by clicking here.

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Sarah Isgur is a senior editor at The Dispatch and is based in Texas. Prior to joining the company in 2019, she had worked in every branch of the federal government and on three presidential campaigns. She’s also an ABC News contributor and the New York Times bestselling author of Last Branch Standing, a deep dive into the inner workings of the Supreme Court. When Sarah is not hosting podcasts or writing newsletters, she’s probably sending uplifting stories about spiders to Jonah, who only pretends to love all animals.

David French is a columnist for the New York Times. He’s a former senior editor of The Dispatch. He’s the author most recently of Divided We Fall: America's Secession Threat and How to Restore Our Nation.

The podcast transcription below was generated using artificial intelligence and may include occasional errors or misspellings.

Music

You ready?

Music

I was born ready.

Sarah Isgur

[upbeat music] Welcome to Advisory Opinions. I'm Sarah Isgur, that's David French. The IRS lawsuit brought by President Trump has been dismissed. Why are David and I still so mad about it? As well as the Supreme Court issues a stay in the Fifth Circuit's mifepristone decision. That decision will not go into effect until cert is granted or denied. We have a big decision from the Supreme Court. It was unanimous, and no one will care, except me. I do. I wanna talk about it, and I've watched trucking YouTube videos to prove it, my friends. And finally, celebrity trials. David likes them, I don't. Let's talk about Allen charges. All this and more on Advisory Opinions. All right, David, we try to start with the newsiest thing, and this one is an IRS lawsuit. Who would've guessed in the year our Lord, 2026, the newsiest thing we have to talk about is the dismissal of an IRS lawsuit. Uh, but David, here we are. This is Donald Trump's lawsuit against the IRS for basically negligence in allowing his tax returns to be leaked. We have talked about this case before, David, and we said, "Set aside everything else, the names, whatever, just the facts as alleged, would absolutely give rise to a pretty successful lawsuit in normal times." The difference here, of course, is that it's Donald Trump, who's the sitting president, and the IRS is part of the executive branch, and guess what? So is the Department of Justice, and so the judge in this case, very smartly, was asking questions about whether this was in fact an adversarial proceeding when it was the sitting president of the United States versus his own Department of Justice, and therefore, like, was this a case or controversy under the Constitution? You know, just asking questions. So that, I think, tipped them off that this was headed nowhere good. Uh, David, in normal times, if you really wanted to bring this lawsuit and you were president, I would argue that the normal thing to do would be to file the lawsuit and then ask for the lawsuit itself to be held in abeyance, meaning that, um, it basically is frozen in time, but you also freeze the statute of limitations and everything else, and then it could be picked back up when there is an adversarial proceeding when Donald Trump has left office. But that's not what they were talking about doing. But David, as of Monday morning, the lawsuit has just been dismissed. The whole thing is gone. Instead,

Sarah Isgur

the White House is talking about creating a 1.7 billion, with a B, dollar fund to pay out victims of Joe Biden's DOJ's weaponization. Uh, Donald Trump, they say, will not be a beneficiary of this fund. And David, we talked about this a little on ABC this week on Sunday with George Stephanopoulos, and he seemed surprised when I mentioned Obama's third-party settlements, and that while I totally agree that this is, like, much worse and Donald Trump turning it up to 11 and all of that stuff, nevertheless, the existence of this idea, once again, like government by executive order, seems to have really picked up pace during the Obama administration. Uh, and David, I, I just went back to refresh myself on what exactly was involved back then, so let me read you some coverage from the time. The Obama administration, primarily DOJ, negotiated settlements which required the settling defendants to pay, quote, "donations" to hundreds of its favored politically friendly third parties, such as the National Council of La Raza, the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation, and the National Community Reinvestment Coalition. These third parties were not parties to the litigations nor victims of alleged misbehavior. The Obama Department of Justice offered to reduce the overall settlement monetary amount depending on how much the settling party paid to the favored third parties, calling the quid pro quo reduction an, quote, "enhanced credit." In fact, for every dollar the banks donated, they received $2 credited towards their settlement reductions. And as you might suspect, David, third-party political allies successfully started lobbying the Obama Department of Justice for these settlement monies, and the Obama Department of Justice made sure that organizations which were not aligned with the administration's political preferences, such as Pacific Legal Foundation, did not receive nor secondarily benefit from these monies. Uh, so David, this was widely, you know, criticized during the Obama administration for exactly what it was, right? These sort of, um, appropriations that didn't run through Congress that you could get private parties to pay through litigation coercion and offered settlements and these credits. Uh, so while Congress didn't give any money to La Raza, no money was appropriated, nevertheless, instead of settlement money going into Treasury, it did not go to the Treasury, it went to these third-party groups. Okay. So David, this Trump thing is different because this is not a negotiated settlement because the judge would have to have overseen that settlement, and they want to avoid that. Nevertheless, it reads exactly like a third-party settlement, something, by the way, that when I was at DOJ, we literally banned and put out a very big letterBanning third-party settlements. So here they are once again, horseshoe politics, right? We do not have two different political parties. We have basically total agreement on what the government is for. The only question is what you're gonna use that power to do. That's it.

David French

Well, you know, sue and settle in the Obama administration was a big problem, and it wasn't just money, it was policy. So, you know, normally when you're the federal government, you make policy, you'll have a federal statute that is passed, you'll have a

Interactive transcripts are available to Premium members. Join to follow along with the audio.

Join Now

More We Think You’d Like

Loading