Skip to content

Our Best Stuff From a Very Nerve-Wracking Week

President Trump backs down on his threat to destroy Iran.
Rachael Larimore /
A man in a dark suit speaks at a podium bearing the Presidential Seal in the White House Briefing Room, flanked by two officials, while an audience applauds in the foreground.
President Donald Trump, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, and Joint Chiefs Chairman Gen. Dan Caine conduct a news conference about the war in Iran on Monday, April 6, 2026. (Tom Williams/CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images)

Hello. Tuesday was a very strange day for those of us in the news business. After President Donald Trump posted on Easter Sunday that, “Tuesday will be Power Plant Day, and Bridge Day, all wrapped up in one, in Iran. There will be nothing like it!!!” he followed up Tuesday morning: “A whole civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again. I don’t want that to happen, but it probably will.” We now know “that” didn’t happen—a (very tentative) ceasefire was announced shortly before Trump’s 8 p.m. deadline. But the specter of an attack that promised a humanitarian disaster at best and genocide at worst was unsettling, to say the least. 

For journalists, it’s also a bit paralyzing. A big part of our job is responding to events … but we had no way of knowing what would happen. I reached out to contributors who are foreign policy experts to get their take. I stared at a piece I was trying to edit on the shortcomings of the U.S. strategy and realized it needed to wait or be reframed—all while grappling with the possibility that we could wake up to a profound humanitarian and geopolitical crisis. 

As the world waited, Nick Catoggio kept busy. In Tuesday’s Boiling Frogs, he wrote about the backlash to the war from right-wing figures such as Tucker Carlson, Alex Jones, and Marjorie Taylor Greene, who have all publicly condemned the president’s decision to attack Iran. But he is not particularly impressed by their stances:

They wanted a “disrupter” as president, and they got one. Suddenly, they’re mortified to discover that you need to take the bitter with the sweet when you empower an elderly sociopath who relishes ruthlessly dominating adversaries and is willing to disrupt any institution to serve his own interests. Sometimes he’ll own the libs here at home, other times he might end Iranian civilization via a massive war-crimes campaign. 

Carlson, Jones, Greene, and their ilk assumed that Trump would disrupt only the things they wanted to disrupt, and they gambled the stability of the United States on their being right.

My husband and I were at a parents meeting Tuesday evening for our youngest’s upcoming school trip to Europe when he nudged me and showed me the news alert on his phone: There would be a ceasefire Whew. However one might feel about the Iranian regime generally or the merits of this conflict specifically, Trump’s threats were chilling, not only regarding the fate of the Iranian people but also for the stability of the Middle East and for the consciences of the troops who would have been asked to carry out potentially illegal orders.

But there are also consequences to a president backing down from a horrific threat. As Kevin D. Williamson wrote on Friday, the ceasefire works to Iran’s considerable advantage and reflects the fact that the regime understands Trump better than the United States understands the regime:

Trump’s escalating threats against Iran leapt very quickly from mere war crimes (targeting civilian infrastructure) to outright genocide (“a whole civilization will die tonight”), and the bosses in Tehran ran that through their Trump decoder rings to reveal the true message: “I am terrified by the closing of the Strait of Hormuz and have no idea how to get myself out of this mess.” 

Tehran took him up on his ceasefire talk not because the ayatollahs were cowed by his imbecilic threats but because a ceasefire works to their advantage and costs them, for the moment, nothing.

As for the ceasefire itself, Nick wondered whether Trump understood the specifics of Iran’s demands, noting that the regime issued two statements—a simpler one saying that “passage through the Strait of Hormuz will be possible via coordination with Iran’s Armed Forces and with due consideration of technical limitations” and a more in-depth version with 10 demands, including the lifting of all sanctions and the withdrawal of combat forces from the region. The president called the second statement a “fraud” and castigated CNN for discussing it. Nick wrote:

There’s no deal here. To all appearances, the only meeting of the minds that occurred between the two sides was on the narrow point that ending Iranian civilization would be a bad idea. We’re in the same place we’ve been for the past six weeks, struggling to reconcile the parties’ irreconcilable demands, except now with a fragile ceasefire in place that will hopefully compel both to choose painful compromise over a resumption of hostilities.

Is a TACO a TACO if it’s not filled with anything (yet)?

How did we get here? That’s a question Michael Warren explored this week. He noted that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Joint Chiefs Chairman Gen. Dan Caine gave a press conference Wednesday essentially declaring victory and running through a list of the U.S. military’s many tactical achievements: how many targets were hit, the degree to which Iran’s capabilities and resources were reduced, etc. But that is not the whole story, Mike explained:

The throughline in the administration’s defense of this war has been a focus on these incredible military achievements and our tactical superiority. But largely missing—both in Hegseth’s remarks and the broader case for the war’s success—is any indication that the United States is focused on and achieving the right strategic goals in Iran. Yes, America can effectively and efficiently blow things up, target and kill enemy leaders, and degrade the enemy’s own capabilities. But have we significantly advanced our interests in the region?

As I write this on Friday afternoon, Vice President J.D. Vance was en route to Pakistan for peace talks with Iran scheduled for Saturday, but the regime was adding to its list of demands to engage in negotiations. Meanwhile, the president was using his social media platform to insult the Iranians. Once again, we wait nervously. 

Thank you for reading, and have a good weekend.

From the moment he arrived in Montgomery to the end of his life, Martin Luther King Jr.’s work reflected his commitment to serving others by helping them see the best qualities in themselves and in their nation. If he could just reach one more gang member mired in poverty, one more white moderate, one more disillusioned black leader with his message of persistence, faith, and democratic renewal, then the promise of America—a nation founded on the principle of individual human dignity—might yet be redeemed. “I can’t lose hope,” King once said, “because when you lose hope, you die.” It was this hope, this stubborn faith, that America’s “jangling discords” of racism and inequality could be transformed into a “beautiful symphony of brotherhood,” which carried him to Memphis. The theme of King’s final address in Memphis on April 3, 1968, was acceptance, not only of his own mortality, but of his place in history. Indeed, despite the setbacks of recent years, he appeared more confident than ever as the leader of a movement whose aspirations for moral reform transcended any one man or lifetime. Rather than giving in to cynicism over the long struggle to advance the cause of human freedom, King expressed gratitude for being alive at this “great period of history,” and for the opportunity to lead America toward the promised land of an integrated society. Tracing human development from ancient Rome to the 20th century, King explained that what he learned from history—and what his opponents did not understand—was that history is not a static record of things that somehow happened; it is shaped by human beings and contains a discernible record of progress toward eternal truths.

Wilbraham & Monson was a last-stop sort of place, one of those perpetually dying prep schools that dot the hills of New England, trading on the grandeur of the word “academy” to attract students who have washed out of other schools, or for some reason who need a fresh start. At Wilbraham & Monson, many of the day students had dyslexia, hyperactivity, and the like; others, by contrast, were advanced learners, drawn by the school’s promise that we could speed ahead in our studies (which was true—in seventh grade, I was taking some ninth-grade classes). The boarders were more likely to be discipline cases, with pasts that they preferred not to discuss. And then there was Joe—not a delinquent, just legless. When I arrived for seventh grade, Joe was in his second year, and he was, understandably, the most recognizable student in the place. He was a genuine extrovert, and we’d have met sooner or later, but it happened early in the fall, when I joined the debate team. We bonded over our mutual disdain for some of the effete preppies in the club with us—as a Jersey Italian who bragged that his mob moniker was Joey Bag of Donuts, Joe had no more use for pompous Charles McGuire IV (yes, his real name) than I did. When Charles would talk about his boat or his summer house, Joe would shoot me a look that was easily read as What an a–hole. That was the beginning of our friendship. But what really drew us together was our love of chess. Chess is a game for wastrels and losers, the kind of people who’d rather see a game through to the end than get to class on time or finish a term paper.

Pam Bondi, lately the attorney general of these United States, is an exemplary specimen of the sort of people who thrive in Donald Trump’s orbit: She is in a profound moral sense a criminal, but we lack an appropriate law under which to prosecute her. Bondi’s 14-month career at the Department of Justice was, as a matter of her official duties, a crime spree. Her legacy is that she used the DOJ to launch a series of pretextual criminal investigations and prosecutions targeting the president’s political enemies, even when there was not the hint of an actual legal case to be made against them. Those targeted by Bondi’s DOJ as a matter of political vendetta include: Gov. Tim Walz, Attorney General Keith Ellison, and Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty, all of Minnesota; Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey; St. Paul Mayor Kaohly Her; Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell; Federal Reserve Gov. Lisa Cook; Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan; Rep. Jason Crow of Colorado; Rep. Maggie Goodlander of New Hampshire; Reps. Chrissy Houlahan and Chris Deluzio of Pennsylvania; Sen. Mark Kelly of Arizona; Sen. Adam Schiff of California; former FBI Director James Comey; former CIA Director John Brennan; Attorney General Letitia James of New York. (The prosecution of former National Security Adviser John Bolton, no less political and pretextual where Bondi was concerned, is more complicated in that it is not solely the work of the Trump administration.) That is quite a list—other than printing up a bunch of fake “Epstein files” binders, Bondi seems to have done very little with her time in office other than abuse the awesome powers of the DOJ to abuse, harass, and conduct retribution against the president’s political enemies.

Best of the Rest

# Alt Text A silhouetted profile of a person with an open mind depicted as a leaf shape inside their head, set against overlapping blue circles on a gradient pink-to-blue background.

Trans Issues Are No Conspiracy

Jesse Singal /

The public pays attention to trans issues because trans activists wanted them to.

Two men in dark suits stand on a stage surrounded by a large crowd holding cameras and small flags, with one man waving to the audience in this black and white photograph.

Mr. Vance Goes to Hungary

Jonah Goldberg /

Why the vice president is campaigning for Viktor Orbán.

The facade of the New York Stock Exchange building displays classical Corinthian columns and sculptural pediment details, with American flags flanking the entrance while pedestrians walk in front.

Is Private Credit in Trouble?

Alex Demas, Peter Gattuso, & Ross Anderson /

Plus: Artemis II astronauts break a distance record, and the Supreme Court sends Bannon’s contempt case back to a lower court.

An aerial view of a dense residential neighborhood featuring rows of identical single-family homes with terracotta tile roofs, cream-colored walls, and tall cypress trees casting long shadows across the suburban development.

Affordability Theater Is a Band-Aid, Not a Cure

Jeremiah Johnson /

Short-term solutions don’t typically lead to long-term affordability.

A silhouetted bear holds a small white cube against a vibrant red background.

Whatever Happened to Being Sorry?

Max Heine /

So much of culture parrots the Christian church’s deemphasis on repentance.

A person viewed from behind gazes at the Iranian flag waving against a light blue sky.

A Peaceful Uneasy Feeling

Mike Nelson /

Trump backed down from his over-the-top threats but ceded leverage to Iran with the ceasefire.

A businessman in a dark suit holding a briefcase walks in front of a large blue world map on a beige background.

Trump’s Animus Against NATO Could Lead to a Geopolitical Disaster

The alliance has brought decades of peace to Europe and enabled the U.S. to shape events on the continent.

# Alt Text Two black and white portraits of U.S. political figures overlaid with text from the War Powers Resolution (Public Law 93-148) dated November 7, 1973, displaying sections concerning congressional and presidential war powers.

Two Cheers for the War Powers Act

Paul D. Miller /

The Vietnam-era legislation is imperfect, but it’s the best we’ve got.

ADVISORY OPINIONS SITE THUMB (3392 x 1696 px)

Trump’s ‘War Crimes’

Sarah Isgur & David French /

Can a threat of a war crime be in and of itself a war crime?

Dispatch Podcast Generic (3392 x 1696 px)

The Department of Justice After Pam Bondi

What to expect from Trump's next attorney general.

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Rachael Larimore is a managing editor of The Dispatch and is based in the Cincinnati area. Prior to joining the company in 2019, she served in similar roles at Slate, The Weekly Standard, and The Bulwark. She and her husband have three sons.

Newsletter selected

Click sign up to start receiving your newsletters.

More We Think You’d Like

Newsletter selected

Click sign up to start receiving your newsletters.

Loading