Turn any article into a podcast. Upgrade now to start listening.
Members can share articles with friends & family to bypass the paywall.
Hello. President Donald Trump on Wednesday signed a memorandum of understanding bringing an end to the fighting in Iran. The 14-point plan calls for the U.S. to end its blockade of Iranian ports, for Iran to open the Strait of Hormuz and not charge tolls for 60 days, and for the U.S. to lift all sanctions on Iran and restore frozen funds. In addition, Iran will be eligible to receive $300 billion for reconstruction and economic development (from a private fund that is being established). So the fighting ends, the U.S. leaves, and Iran gets loaded up with cash.
Contributing writer Mike Nelson has one word to describe the deal: “surrender.” He notes that Iran successfully played Trump by taking over the strait, writing, “While a return to the free flow of global commerce is inherently good and necessary, we shouldn’t chalk this up as a win. Like a magician using distraction to pull off a trick, Iran made the war about the strait and the economic woes its disruption caused, getting the administration to take its eye off the causes for initiating the war and any of the goals it said we would achieve through it.”
Of course, Trump claimed, precisely, that the deal “achieves everything we set out to accomplish and much more.” In the Wednesday G-File, Jonah Goldberg took that claim apart:
The three objectives he cited: “ending the current conflict,” “reopening the Strait of Hormuz,” and “preventing Iran from ever obtaining a nuclear weapon.” He added, “That’s what it was all about.” So by his own accounting a goal of the war he started was to end the war he started. Another was to open a waterway that was open until he started it. And to prevent Iran from ever getting a nuclear weapon, which he has not done.
Jonah also touched on why no one should be surprised that the war turned out like this, writing, “He does what he does for reasons having to do with his self-interest. That’s it. It’s not more complicated than that. If he can do the right thing easily and at low cost, he’ll do the right thing if he gets the credit for it. If it becomes hard, boring, costly, or embarrassing, he’ll give up or reverse course.”
Given that the deal can’t exactly be spun as a victory for the United States, Nick Catoggio wonders why Vice President J.D. Vance seems so eager to be the face of it. He was scheduled to attend the signing ceremony in Switzerland on Friday before news broke that Trump had signed the deal virtually on Wednesday, and he made the talk-show rounds to sell it.
Nick suspects it’s both a nod to the isolationist wing of the party ahead of the 2028 presidential race and a hunch that by the time the election comes around, Americans will mostly remember the war as a failure. Nick writes:
All the charisma and grassroots energy is on that side of the party. Ted Cruz isn’t going to successfully primary J.D. Vance by calling him an Obama-esque weakling for brokering a deal blessed by Donald Trump, but a passionate Lindberghian demagogue like Tucker Carlson could cause trouble by accusing the vice president—and his boss—of having sold out “America First” by waging a foolish war with Iran. By making himself the face of a peace deal, Vance is hedging against that.
He’s also aligning himself with the vast majority of general election voters. That’s normally a smart thing for a politician to do, no?s
Of course, we probably shouldn’t get too far ahead of ourselves. The 14-point deal also calls for the cessation of hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah, and only Friday morning did those two parties agree to their own ceasefire. Israeli strikes against the Iranian proxy last weekend threatened to derail the announcement of the U.S.-Iran deal, which came Sunday evening after a day of uncertainty. And then there is the matter of Congress, which in 2015 passed the Iran Nuclear Agreement Review Act, which states that the president needs to submit any nuclear deal with Iran to Congress for its approval. Which prompts the question: Is the MOU a “nuclear deal with Iran”? The 14-point plan largely punts on the matter of Iran’s nuclear program, leaving it to the 60-day negotiating period intended to result in a final deal.
In a reported piece, John McCormack noted that “the text of INARA makes no distinctions between interim or final agreements.” But even if Trump should submit the deal to Congress, it doesn’t appear that he intends to. The 14-point plan includes sanctions waivers that begin immediately, but under the law such waivers would be subject to a 30-day congressional review.
There’s one other matter: If Congress wants to review the deal, it would have to get Trump to submit it. And for that reason, one senator John talked to suggested that the whole premise is a little silly.
“Given that Donald Trump is breaking the law by conducting the war without congressional approval, talk about what Congress is legally entitled to do if he ends the war is pretty absurd,” Democratic Sen. Richard Blumenthal told him.
On that note, thank you for reading, and I hope you have a good weekend. And on the off chance you’re still looking for a Father’s Day gift for any special dads in your life, allow me to recommend the gift of The Dispatch.
There are two serious affordability problems in America. They look nothing like each other and need opposite solutions. The first is the destitute tail. A real but small share of Americans are in genuinely miserable financial situations. They have more bills than they can pay. They are one missed paycheck from eviction. They frequently have literally zero money. The unemployable woman with the worthless degree from the fraudulent for-profit college is in this category. So is the 58-year-old who got laid off from a manufacturing job, exhausted his savings, can’t get hired anywhere, and watches his wife work double shifts at Walmart. These people need money. … The second problem is the squeezed-talent class, and it’s harder to explain because the people involved look fine on paper. Picture a 32-year-old physician married to a 32-year-old software engineer. Combined household income, $400,000. They cannot buy a house in San Francisco or Boston or New York within a sane commute of their jobs. They cannot afford to have three kids, pay for childcare, and put them in decent schools. They are doing every single thing the meritocratic American dream told them to do, and the dream is not being delivered. Their parents, at the same age, with worse credentials and lower real incomes, owned a house and had three kids on one salary. Something is broken here, and it isn’t their fault, and it isn’t fixed by transfers.
Of course, we have accepted imperfect presidents. Abraham Lincoln played fast and loose with the law (and, arguably, the Constitution) on occasion. Ulysses S. Grant—while gifted with courage, perseverance, and humility—was a bit short on temperance. John F. Kennedy, who symbolized courage and, to some extent, justice, and tried more often than not to act on principles, did not always exercise good judgment. We have also had less-than-great presidents who nonetheless embodied good character. … Even James Buchanan, perennially ranked by scholars as the worst president, was not lacking in character. In 1920, in part as a rebound from World War I and the 1918 Spanish flu pandemic, Americans overwhelmingly voted for Warren G. Harding and his promise of “normalcy.” While a man who was said to “look like a President,” Harding was not seen as a man of great character. He was described by some as “a jovial, easy-going, shallow man,” and was said to have “brought to the White House the moral code of the hangers-on around a rural county courthouse.” Given the bad memories of the war and the pandemic, it would seem that much of the country wanted nothing more than to be jovial, easygoing, and shallow. Still, almost no one would have characterized Harding as “evil.”
Vance’s opportunistic turn to right-wing Catholicism came when a particular strain of right-wing Catholicism bubbled up as a revivified political current in the swamp that is Vance’s natural political home, “integralism” and “post-liberalism” and all that happy horsepucky. Vance saw a parade and ran to get in front of it, muttering a few “Hail Marys” along the way. Of course he had never done any religious reading heavier than The Screwtape Letters and the Narnia books: There was no juice in that for the future lawyer and finance bro. Judging by Communion, he still hasn’t bothered to read or think seriously about these things. To describe his religious thinking here as superficial would be to extend to Vance a degree of intellectual generosity he has not earned. Vance’s insincerity is comically transparent at times. Some of you will remember the matter of Vance’s trying to capitalize on malicious fictions about (black) immigrants in his native Ohio rampaging through peaceful (white) neighborhoods eating up the cats and dogs. It never happened, and Vance knows it never happened, and Vance has at times halfway admitted that he knows it never happened but seized on the story, anyway, because it was politically useful. Perhaps his religious instructors somehow glossed over the part about “bearing false witness.” As it turns out, a talent for bearing false witness—in the service of a president who has made a point of routinely violating nine out of the Ten Commandments—is really what Vance brings to the party.
Best of the Rest
Can Congress Fix College Sports?
Two pieces of legislation aim to impose order on athlete transfers and compensation, but consensus is proving elusive.
Cuba: Postmortem of the Communist Revolution
Proper reforms can foster economic growth, but change takes time and is disruptive.
Trump and Thune Are Increasingly Out of Sync
The president’s recent political moves have put the Senate majority leader in a series of tight spots.
The AI Race Isn’t About Electricity
Specialized silicon will solve the AI-driven energy panic.
Why the Midterm Odds Might Still Be in the GOP’s Favor
Mid-decade redistricting could be a life preserver for Republicans.
What Does ‘Rural’ Even Mean?
Politicians, surveys, and the Census all use the word. Are they all talking about the same thing?
Would Thomas Edison Recognize Today’s Grid?
Digital technology is pushing our electrical system toward decentralization, transforming the vertical integration model.
The White House’s New Anthropic Restrictions, Explained
The government’s abrupt shuttering of the Fable 5 and Mythos 5 models indicates a lack of coherent AI guidelines.
The Trump Administration’s Internal Arguments Over Habeas Corpus
Plus: Is indefinite detention cruel and unusual?
The Iran Agreement Is Worse Than You Think
Plus: How to celebrate Father's Day.
Abraham Lincoln, the First American | Interview: Allen Guelzo
And the last Founding Father
Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?
Add Us as a Preferred Source















