Skip to content

Our Best Stuff on the Democrats’ Platner Problem

On the fallout from the Maine Senate candidate’s many scandals.
Rachael Larimore /
A bearded man wearing a navy cap and t-shirt speaks passionately at a podium with a microphone, gesturing with his arm outstretched in an indoor venue with blurred signage in the background.
Democratic U.S. Senate candidate Graham Platner speaks during a town hall on May 20, 2026 in Portland, Maine. (Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images)

Hello and happy Saturday. We always knew the 2026 midterms would be dramatic: The Republicans have razor-thin margins in both chambers of Congress, the party in power typically fares poorly, and President Donald Trump has had steadily declining approval ratings. We’ve seen states—red and blue—rush to redraw their congressional maps in order to influence the makeup of the House of Representatives. But the fate of the Senate potentially hinging on a scandal-ridden Democratic candidate in Maine may not have been on our bingo card. 

The group of Senate seats up for election favors Republicans keeping control of the chamber, where they currently have a 53-47 majority. But polling increasingly suggests Democrats could earn a majority. Texas, Iowa, North Carolina, and Ohio are all vulnerable seats for the GOP. Even if the ethically challenged, Trump-endorsed Republican state Attorney General Ken Paxton defeats James Talarico in Texas, there are paths to Democrats winning. Which brings us to Maine, where progressive upstart Graham Platner is poised to win next week’s Democratic primary. 

Platner declared his candidacy last August, but by October he was facing scrutiny over past comments he’d made online and dealing with the revelation that he’d gotten a tattoo that resembled an insignia used by the SS during World War II. Turns out the Nazi tattoo, which Platner covered up, was just the beginning. 

A week ago, the New York Times and Wall Street Journal both reported that Graham’s wife had told campaign aides that he had “sexting” relationships with up to a dozen women, and the WSJ reported that he had an active profile on Kik, a private messaging app “widely used for sexual encounters.”

This created a bit of a pickle for Democrats, even before the New York Times reported on Thursday that former girlfriends of Platner described him as being “demeaning to women and, in at least one case, even physically threatening.” One ex also claimed that Platner knew his tattoo was a Nazi symbol, despite his protestations throughout his campaign that he was unaware. What now? Do Democrats stand behind such a morally challenged candidate in hopes of winning the Senate, or do they risk enduring two more years of a GOP majority carrying out Donald Trump’s agenda?

In Boiling Frogs, Nick wrote that we’ve seen this show before. He recalls Michael Anton’s 2016 essay, “The Flight 93 Election,” noting that it “remains the supreme statement of negative partisanship in modern American politics, a playbook Republicans have since followed to rationalize every form of depravity the president can muster. Nothing that our candidate has done or will do is so terrible, the thinking goes, that it would justify empowering the other party to carry out its existential threat against America.” He calls the essay loathsome, but he also sympathizes with Democrats:

If the election were tight locally and nationally, I would feel pulled morally to vote for the Democrat. The difference between Anton’s “Flight 93” fantasy and our present reality is that the lunatic at the controls really is willing to crash this plane, especially as his senescence deepens. He’s trying to put his face on the money. He’s turning the 250th anniversary of independence into a political rally. He treats trade policy as a royal prerogative, declares major wars without congressional input, has deputized the Justice Department to persecute his enemies, and impugns any election result that reflects badly on him as illegitimate.

In the Wednesday G-File, Jonah Goldberg had his own thoughts about choosing the “lesser of two evils.” He wrote: 

There are two problems with supporting the lesser of two evils. The first is you’re still supporting evil. …

The second problem is that in an era where all notions of small-r republican virtue elicit contempt from anyone who finds virtue inconvenient to their pursuit of power, power becomes the measure of virtue. How many people who said Trump was the lesser evil a decade ago “evolved” to believe that Trump was the avatar of all that is good? His bad character was once a regrettable problem that was outweighed by the need to defeat Hillary Clinton. In short order, the definition of good character was rewritten to fit Trump. The same thing is happening before our eyes with Graham Platner, and I’m sure we’ll get there with Paxton.

Kevin Williamson, meanwhile, took apart the argument from the left that Platner merely is “not perfect.” He wrote:

To say that Platner “isn’t perfect” is to say nothing at all. None of us is perfect. To say that a man is not perfect is akin to saying he is not a giraffe or a Tiffany lampshade. Platner is a man with an SS tattoo and fidelity problems who cannot manage to give a forthright account of either these or many other legitimate concerns about his character and his candidacy. It is not that Graham Platner is not perfect—it is that he is positively bad, not in a merely private sense as some apologists would have it but in the sense of being a bad sort of person to endow with significant political power. Private morality and civic virtue are not the same thing (Cato the Younger was a drunk) but there is a great deal of overlap in that Venn diagram.

The standard for public men is not perfection. To write and speak and argue as though it were is simply a cheap and cowardly rhetorical dodge, one that should always and everywhere be treated with the contempt it deserves.

If you need a palate cleanser after that, we had some really great pieces this week. John McCormack interviewed former Sen. Ben Sasse, who is battling cancer and was given months to live six months ago, about how his family and faith are helping carry him through his fight. And as we get closer to the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, Yuval Levin looks at whether the American experiment is legitimate. Both are highlighted below. Thanks for reading, and have a great weekend.

Ben Sasse’s appeal extends far beyond the terminally ill and their families, of course. His willingness, in the face of death, to speak candidly about his religious faith is what’s moving the young and the old alike. During an April video appearance on New York Times columnist Ross Douthat’s podcast, Sasse’s face was bloodied and covered in scabs—the chemotherapy shrinking his tumors inhibits the growth of skin cells—but Sasse was his typical jocular and jovial self. He made light of the scabs—even though he said his face felt “nuclear”—and joked about the idea of taking up smoking cigarettes outside of M.D. Anderson, the cancer hospital in Houston where he is being treated (lung cancer is one of his five cancers). Sasse also talked broadly about American politics, academia, and his cancer diagnosis, but it was the last 10 minutes of the podcast that were particularly moving. “Are you angry at God ever?” Douthat asked. “No,” Sasse said. “Not at all?” Douthat followed up. “No,” Sasse replied. “I wouldn’t want a sovereign God to defer to all of my prayers with a yes. I’m not omniscient. I don’t know what the weaving together of the tapestry of full redemption should look like, but I know going through the period of suffering that I’m going through is a benefit because it is a winnowing. I’m filled with dross. This suffering is not salvific, but it’s sanctifying, and I’m grateful for it.”

The Constitution, like the Declaration, came together in the summer, in Philadelphia, in what we now call Independence Hall. The two documents were debated and approved in the same room, but 11 years apart. And the experience of those 11 years confirmed the difficulty of the challenge that the Declaration had sketched out. They were seven years of war and four years of peace. The war was fought for self-government, and against abuses of power by a government that was not sufficiently accountable to the people it governed. The revolution came to be understood, at least by the end of the war, as what we might call a struggle for democracy. And the forms of government established in the states during and after the war tended to be radically democratic: Strong legislatures kept close to the people, in several cases through annual elections, and a kind of thoroughgoing majority rule. There was general agreement in America that these republican forms were necessary, and in some respects that they were key to what the war was about. But by the end of the war, and especially in those first years of peace, it also became increasingly clear that these modes of government were not working well.

For nearly a decade, the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency’s (DARPA) Strategic Technology Office has been developing the concept of mosaic warfare, a doctrine intended to replace the U.S. military’s reliance on a few expensive, highly complex platforms with vast networks of cheap, interchangeable systems coordinated in real time by artificial intelligence. The Pentagon published the concept openly, and there were few real detractors—the only question was how quickly and extensively to implement it. Yet in February, when America went to war, it reached for the same tools as before. The mosaic doctrine was nowhere to be found—except, perhaps, in the adversary’s warfighting strategy.Iran has spent the last two decades building something much closer to mosaic warfare. Meanwhile, America’s long-standing failure to translate strategic concepts into operational doctrine, weapons procurement, and policymaker decisions may both doom and outlive this conflict.

Best of the Rest

A blue syringe with a yellow glow radiates from its center against a light gray background, with a black and white portrait visible at the top.

The Ketamine Revolution

Valerie Pavilonis /

Once known as a club drug, ketamine is helping the ‘walking wounded.’

A black serpent coiled around a staff topped with a sphere, positioned at the center of a split red and blue background.

Conservatives and Liberals Have Diverging Health Outcomes. Why?

Grayson Logue /

A new study examines an emerging health gap between Americans on the right and left.

A stylized portrait of a man in formal business attire against a bright red background, rendered in high-contrast pop art style with bold black shadows and simplified features.

Can Mike Pence’s Think Tank Lead Reaganites Out of the Wilderness?

Charles Hilu /

With new money and Heritage defectors, Advancing American Freedom tries to position itself for greater influence within the GOP.

A woman with a white parasol and three children stroll through a wildflower meadow dotted with red poppies beneath a cloudy sky, with a distant village and tree line visible on the horizon.

Motherhood Is Not a Trade

Hannah Anderson /

How education policy reveals our society’s reduction of people to cogs in a machine.

An American flag waves on a flagpole next to a wooden cross against a cloudy sky.

Why American Christianity Became Southern

Daniel K. Williams /

How the Northeast lost its religion and the South kept it.

A tall stack of yellowed papers and documents sits atop a bright red folder against a blue background.

Shining a Light on Regulatory Dark Matter

Kevin D. Williamson /

How ambiguous guidance from government agencies hinders businesses that just want to comply with the law.

A man in a blue suit and striped tie speaks at a podium bearing the Department of Defense seal, gesturing with his hand while addressing an audience against a beige background with decorative elements.

Hegseth’s Officer Purge Is Bad for the Military—And Our Country

Kevin Carroll /

The defense secretary appears to want flag officers who will not challenge potentially illegal orders.

Dispatch Podcast Generic (3392 x 1696 px)

Will Republicans Make Donald Trump a Lame Duck?

Congressional Republicans are beginning to challenge the president openly.

ADVISORY OPINIONS SITE THUMB (3392 x 1696 px)

President Trump’s Losing Streak

Sarah Isgur & David French /

Is it permanent, or just judges gone wild?

REMNANT SITE THUMB (3392 x 1696 px) (1)
Unlocked
The Remnant

Live From the Watergate Hotel! | Interview: Sarah Isgur

Jonah Goldberg /

Don’t try and be Jonah … or Sarah.

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Rachael Larimore is a managing editor of The Dispatch and is based in the Cincinnati area. Prior to joining the company in 2019, she served in similar roles at Slate, The Weekly Standard, and The Bulwark. She and her husband have three sons.

Newsletter selected

Click sign up to start receiving your newsletters.

More We Think You’d Like

Newsletter selected

Click sign up to start receiving your newsletters.

Loading