Among the more frustrating parts of my job are the seemingly endless proposals for government intervention in the economy on the thinnest of “market failure” grounds. Whether it’s trade or manufacturing or housing or child care or the environment, our virtual pages are full of claims that a perceived problem—Rents are too high! We don’t make enough EVs!—is clearly the fault of unfettered market forces and, by extension, thus in need of new (usually “smart” or “targeted”) government intervention that will improve the situation. As economist Maxwell Tabarrok put it earlier this year, “market failure” in econ classes and public policy “is never taught without using it to study and justify government intervention in markets, implicitly or explicitly defining the government as a ‘social welfare maximizer.’” Once you realize this omission, you see it everywhere—including in this brand new think piece in the New York Times on how a Harris administration would magically solve the nation’s economic problems.
As we discussed at length several years ago, a common flaw in such assertions is that problems in a particular market have been caused not by unbridled capitalism and a lack of government intervention but by other forces, often other government policies. In the case of U.S. Steel, I explained back then, the company had benefited from decades of government support—protectionism, subsidies, bailouts, regulatory exemptions, procurement mandates, etc.—and, far from being a claimed market failure, its recent abandonment of a Pennsylvania steel mill project was “precisely what the economics literature anticipates” from a sputtering, state-sponsored oligopolist. Dig through past editions of Capitolism and you’ll find many other examples of fake “market failures” justifying even more government intervention. As The Atlantic’s Jerusalem Demsas and others have pointed out, that NYT piece was similarly misguided:
But perhaps the best example of this mistake is baby formula, which interventionist types bizarrely keep citing as a market failure when anyone actually examining the issue—including the uber-interventionist Federal Trade Commission and this brand new report from the National Academy of Sciences—acknowledges that pervasive government regulation both contributed greatly to the supply chain crisis of 2022 and thwarted the U.S. market’s recovery.
(Toldja.)
Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?
Add Us as a Preferred Source



