Skip to content
Patrick G. Eddington /

Keep the National Guard Out of Local Crime-Fighting

Why throwing the Guardsmen at crime is a bad idea (and what actually works).
A group of soldiers walking up a staircase
Illustration by Noah Hickey/The Dispatch (Photos via Getty Images).
In our polarized era, there are fewer and fewer spaces where people who disagree can do so productively and in good faith. The Dispatch’s Debate Series aims to be an outlier: a regular feature where two writers with opposing views can hash out some of the thorniest political and cultural issues roiling the national conversation. If you have an idea for a future topic, please let us know at debates@thedispatch.com.

President Donald Trump claims many major American cities are criminal hellscapes so unsafe that only by deploying uniformed and armed National Guard personnel—or even U.S. Marines—can we solve the problem. Is his reading accurate?

I spent 11 years in the National Guard and Army Reserve and was part of a group of Missouri Guard personnel called up to assist with post-tornado security and anti-looting operations in my hometown of Springfield, Missouri, in April 1983.

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Patrick G. Eddington is a senior fellow in homeland security and civil liberties at the Cato Institute and author of The Triumph of Fear: Domestic Surveillance and Political Repression From McKinley Through Eisenhower.

Read the Counterpoint

Loading