Skip to content
Tal Fortgang /

Useless at Best, Murderous at Worst

Adam Kirsch’s ‘On Settler Colonialism’ captures the futility of the anti-Israel ideology—but undersells its danger.
Students at George Washington University continue to pro-Palestine demonstration
Student protestors gather at George Washington University on April 26, 2024. (Photo by Celal Gunes/Anadolu via Getty Images)

Rumors of the death of ideas have been greatly exaggerated. Our politics may run on vibes, and some combination of influencers and tribal loyalty may shape Americans’ intuitions. Yet there is still a throughline between ascendant ideas and important policy decisions. 

It can happen like this: Young people, their approval and votes coveted by tastemakers and policymakers, embrace an idea so exotic they cannot muster the lexicon or courage to question it; that idea shapes their general orientation toward a hot-button political issue, like race or the Middle East; political campaigns rush to capitalize on this new-found enthusiasm with some policy item that resonates with that orientation, like an arms embargo on an ally fighting a war against several enemy proxies.

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Tal Fortgang is a contributing writer for The Dispatch and legal policy fellow at the Manhattan Institute.

More Recent Book Reviews

Loading