Skip to content
Nicole Penn /

When Fate, Not Reason, Ruled Us

Robert Eggers’ films go beyond mere caricature of history to truly resurrect the fate-haunted mind.
A red circle with trees in the background
Illustration by Noah Hickey/The Dispatch (Photos via Getty Images).

To us moderns, the most unsettling part of Robert Eggers’ 2015 movie The Witch isn’t really the titular character, or the dark woods from which she torments a Puritan family, or the black goat that spends the film leering at them knowingly. Rather, it’s a conversation the patriarch William has with his son Caleb as they search for the family’s baby, who has been spirited away for ungodly ends.

Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?

Add Us as a Preferred Source

Nicole Penn is assistant director for social, cultural, and constitutional studies at the American Enterprise Institute. She is also a doctoral student in American history at George Mason University.

More on Movies

Loading