Turn any article into a podcast. Upgrade now to start listening.
Members can share articles with friends & family to bypass the paywall.
Editor’s Note: This is the sixth entry in a new Dispatch series titled “Where I’m From.” Every Saturday, a writer will share a meditation on his or her hometown—a bustling metropolis, distant desert outpost, quiet suburb, or somewhere in between—and what makes it unique. The goal? Highlight voices—and good writing—from every corner of these United States.
“Sheboygan. Very big in Sheboygan,” reminisced John Candy’s polka-playing Gus Polinski in Home Alone. Six hundred and twenty-three fictional albums sold in a city that’s swapped between either side of 50,000 since 1970—not bad for a night of Germanic accordion-crunching at the Elks Club on Erie Avenue.
Like New York state’s Schenectady—an area from which some of Sheboygan’s earliest white men sallied—Sheboygan is a toothsome name for a water-limned city that is never submerged for long before being rediscovered by popular culture. New acquaintances chuckle upon hearing a Sheboyganite’s place of origin, swishing its elements like sommeliers before turning to a friend and hollering, “Hey! Joe! This guy’s from Shah-BOY-gihn!”
The joke in town is, it’s an old Indian name that came about after the wife of a Menominee chief bore him yet another son: “She-had-a-boy-again.” The actual etymology is anglicized Menominee; “Sheboygan” being the product of Yankee and German tongues attempting Sāpīwaehekaneh—“at a hearing distance in the woods” or “great noise underground” (likely a reference to Sheboygan’s inland waterfalls).
This city and its beaches, with their pacific blue waters during the summer months (which has earned us the moniker “Malibu of the Midwest”) and tempestuous, Gordon Lightfoot-inspiring gray deeps during winter, is forever home. This attachment, already firm for me as a teen (when a good number of classmates wanted nothing more than to be gone), became concrete during my years away. Charleston and Coronado are fine places to live, both effortlessly beautiful, and the 250,000 nautical miles in the U.S. Navy’s bilges and maintenance shops were certainly an experience for which I remain grateful, but the snatches of days home on leave had more life and light in them than the months away.
As my wife, a FIB-turned-Texan who summered in Sheboygan, has observed: Everyone can be the main character in Sheboygan. She should know. At a young age, she had resolved to marry a Sheboygan boy, and I, her sailing instructor in 2012, remain a grateful target of that objective. We made it official in Fountain Park Methodist in 2016.
Speaking of churches, Sheboygan can be understood as a Reaganite three-legged stool: churches, cheese, and chairs. The only caveat is that there’s a silent “b” for bars. There’s a church on almost every corner; the absence of a steeple on a thoroughfare means the tavern league beat congregants to the spot (or the congregants didn’t want the priest seeing their post-Communion return to the cup). One of America’s most pickled cities, Sheboygan boasts 3 Sheeps Brewing, sun-faded Pabst Blue Ribbon signs, and Wisconsin-exclusive Spotted Cow on tap, and in the cooler, for the tourists.
A port town when the Great Lakes were the medium of choice for moving freight and men, Sheboygan’s waterfront retains some of a sailor’s preferred landmarks, with the Harbor Lights bar having (allegedly) spent time as a brothel, and during Prohibition was one of the speakeasies connected via tunnel with other dens of vice. My dad, a sheriff’s deputy whose station was just up the hill from there, would occasionally call the dispatcher who lived above Harbor Lights at the time and ask him to turn on “the lamp.” This was no ordinary lamp; it was a replica of the leg lamp from A Christmas Story that the dispatcher had displayed just so in the second-story turret. My sister and I would look out the windows of the family 1995 Honda Odyssey in awe.
But Sheboygan is much less of an open-air saloon than these headline-grabbing rankings imply. The city was, from the beginning, a place of new starts. We were the end of the Great Lakes shipping line if one didn’t want to go on to Milwaukee or Chicago. Sheboygan’s influx of Germans, Dutchmen, and Irishmen in the middle of the 19th century meant high- and low-church Lutherans and Calvinists were rubbing elbows with the Catholics.
Tragedy was not uncommon on the Great Lakes; the sunk-and-recovered hulk of the Lottie Cooper residing across from the marina can testify to that fact, and is just one example of the hundreds of turn-of-the-century wooden ships that populate the bottom of the vast inland sea we call Lake Michigan. Perhaps the most grisly local wreck was the November 1847 explosion of the unfortunately named SS Phoenix. Originally departing from Buffalo, the Phoenix was within sight of Sheboygan with approximately 300 souls aboard when the boilers exploded. By the time rescuers could sail out and begin to assist, there were but 43 survivors.
Life went on. The north side’s shoreline was historically the Dutch ghetto, and it was there that my alma mater, Sheboygan Christian, was started by concerned Calvinists in 1898 as a response to the secular schools. We would play basketball against the Catholics through grade school, with the Lutherans maintaining a league of their own, complete with their own catechism of drive-and-dish tactics. True to form, the Catholics of Holy Family would show no mercy to us, the children of Huguenots. Sheboygan’s son, Sam Dekker, who led the Wisconsin Badgers to a miracle victory over the 38-0 Kentucky Wildcats in March Madness 2015, is an exaggerated build of our city’s offspring: Well over 6 feet tall, thin as a garden tractor’s PTO shaft, and lethal from range. This is also why Sheboygan’s North and South high schools have never had success at football.
Until my parents returned to Sheboygan in the 1990s—my dad to patrol the county as a deputy and my mom to teach at the county jail—the last time a member of our family had lived in Sheboygan was when my maternal great-grandfather came from Germany in the 1920s and split time in the city between a bakery and Kohler Company’s factory. As Great Lakes shipping slowed, Sheboygan became the place for Kohler’s blue-collar employees to live. The white-collar, non-union types lived on the periphery.
For no small few, Sheboygan is synonymous with Kohler: Its bathroom fixtures, its coffee garden, and maybe most of all, its championship-caliber golf courses, Whistling Straits being preeminent among these. Growing up with friends whose parents were on both sides of the Kohler picket line and mass layoffs at various points, it was, in those rare instances, an uncomfortable situation for everyone, in what was most of the time the communitarian ideal of healthy, happy, unbroken families. None of the families with whom I grew up has divorced (a blessing that I did not realize until two days into boot camp, learning of many of my peers’ fractured home lives).
Similarly, the Kohlers are a family that has, and continues to, spend a significant amount of money and time developing Sheboygan’s art and culture scene. While some in town grumble about the family’s billions in Bernie-esque fashion, the area would be a shadow of itself if not for the Kohlers. This is evidenced in their creation and support for the free, world-class John Michael Kohler Arts Center, with, fittingly, the most stunning men’s restroom not owned by a sheikh (opinions differ on the women’s loo … I’m a critic), Bookworm Gardens that bring favorite childhood story locations to life at near-scale, and Sheboygan Youth Sailing, just to name a few.
Not many know that the recently deceased Herb Kohler was a victorious rival of our president’s in the pursuit of acquiring Hamilton Hall overlooking St. Andrew’s historic 18th green on the Old Course in Scotland. Whatever one’s loyalties about plumbing, we should all be grateful that Herb won out, as the glare from a Trump-gilded Hamilton Hall would make any golfing event unwatchable.
While we’re on the topic of things golden and orange, cheese may be Wisconsin’s raison d’être, but Sheboygan is more than a dairy destination. Madison may get huffy about it, but the Brat Capital of the World is an hour south of Green Bay, in none other than Sheboygan. Pulled from a domestic-beer brine, the worthy sausage is placed on a grill to be “fried,” not grilled. An invitation to a brat fry is a matter of course, and one should expect a 40-year-old black rectangle of a radio to be crackling on a nearby table, with, until very recently, Bob Uecker’s anecdotes and calls. A Fourth of July parade along the lakeshore is incomplete without the Johnsonville Sausage trailer or anthropomorphized links cruising by.
The last leg of the Sheboygan stool is chairs, and it, like many of the Midwestern master-crafted trades, is not what it was. The factories along the Sheboygan River that used to house the largest of these manufacturers have been torn down or made into storage. However, for a time in the 19th century, the combination of water-generated power, timber, and Germans met the growing country’s demands for places to sit for a spell. Check the bottom of the antique furniture in your house, and you may be in for a happy surprise. The longest-observed legacy of Sheboygan’s chair industry is whatever the EPA finds in the Sheboygan River’s silt. There’s probably a reason the old varnishes lasted as long as they did. So don’t go eating sand out of the river … really, solid advice in any locality.
Sheboygan is a city where Rockwellian childhood was the norm. Anywhere our bikes could take us, that’s where my buddies and I went. It has its sinners, villains, and plenty more saints. I grew up with an excerpt from Sam Walter Foss on the wall of our home:
Let me live in a house by the side of the road
Where the race of men go by-
The men who are good and the men who are bad,
As good and as bad as I.
I would not sit in the scorner’s seat
Nor hurl the cynic’s ban-
Let me live in a house by the side of the road
And be a friend to man.
From our family home near the lakeshore, I watched my parents live that out, aiding former students, the snowbound, and newcomers. The latest people to find a new life in Sheboygan are the Hmong, our allies from Vietnam. They aided us in the hills and jungles, and we set them up in a Scandinavian climate, albeit with better fish fry (they bring the transparent-noodle eggrolls). The Hmong war memorial at Deland Park, just a couple hundred yards from the waterline, tallies their war dead and heroes—our heroes.
Look past that memorial to the lake and, if the wind and waves are high, you’ll see surfers in wetsuits in January and February merrily carving the freshwater chop—my SoCal Navy buddies to this day refuse to believe one can surf in Lake Michigan. Maybe they’re right; I sailed across it in a day, after all.
Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?
Add Us as a Preferred Source



