Turn any article into a podcast. Upgrade now to start listening.
Members can share articles with friends & family to bypass the paywall.
The recent scuffle between Pope Leo XIV and the Trump administration, Vice President J.D. Vance in particular, reveals a great deal about the role faith principles play in shaping (and not shaping) those in public life. This ugly episode confirms what our era has been teaching us: America would be far healthier if more of our leaders were faithful to principles instead of partisanship, pique, or personal ambition.
For those of us born and raised into the Catholic Church, it’s tough to separate the teachings of the faith from the views we hold as adults. When your parents and extended family members are Catholic and when you’re going to weekly Mass and Sunday school, you are continuously, if subtly, shaped by the church’s principles and practices.
Sure, my ego wants to believe that I’m pro-life, favor school choice, support a strong civil society, and feel a duty to serve the public thanks to my reason. But the truth is I was formed by a religious tradition. And this particular religious tradition has values informed by centuries of scholarship and on-the-ground experience with the human condition and the challenges of public life.
No one could memorize all of the church’s social teachings, but a “cradle Catholic” has a lifetime of homilies, Bible readings, confirmation classes, and service projects to fall back on. Together, they give us a sense of the faith’s unbending commitment to the disadvantaged, its protectiveness of innocent human life, and rules about individuals’ interdependence and responsibilities. We also have a sense of humility: We know that the church’s positions existed long before us and don’t bend to our preferences. We come to know that the church earned its wisdom the hard way: Over the course of 2,000 years, it has dealt with countless monarchs, faced down dictators, provided aid to the poor and the sick, run hospitals and schools, witnessed the rise of democracy and the fall of empires, and experienced the costs of totalitarianism and war.
We also learn that the church’s views don’t neatly align with those of any political party or any contemporary public leader. A libertarian might not like the obligations associated with solidarity. A progressive might not like the distribution of authority required by subsidiarity. Those who appreciate the church’s opposition to capital punishment might be put off by its opposition to abortion and assisted suicide.
All of the above are simply the real-world consequences of being guided by a firm, venerable faith tradition while engaging in public life.
It makes me smile to read that many adults are now joining the church. This Easter (a traditional time for inductions into the faith), many dioceses reported big increases in the number of initiations. I would never presume to know, much less judge, why these adults made the choice. It could be a spiritual calling or an attraction to the sacraments. The appeal of tradition or the search for truth. The faith’s historical continuity or universal community. Whatever the reason, these adults, unlike those of us born into the church, joined entirely of their own volition.
For that, they deserve admiration and respect. They also deserve time for learning and discernment. And they deserve grace because of a particular challenge they face: They come to the faith with many of their political views already established. Unlike someone born into the faith—those whose views are formed from the very start by the church—these adults can easily separate what they have come to believe from what the faith teaches. And these adults then must choose.
A person with no connection to church will have no problem here. She believes one thing; the church teaches another; unobligated by the faith, she sides with herself. For instance, President Trump, a non-Catholic, had no compunction about deriding the pope’s views on crime and foreign policy.
Public officials who are Catholic don’t have it that easy. Some have handled this kind of conflict by saying, essentially, that while the faith informs their personal opinions and conduct, they will set their own course on public matters. This has been a common approach among liberal Catholic politicians who support abortion rights. But it might also be used by those who support the death penalty, enhanced interrogations in exigent situations, or the aggressive use of military force. In such cases, a leader might say, “My heart follows the church, but my vote is mine alone.”
I’ll leave it to the clergy to explain when and how the church approves of that kind of private-public distinction. But when officials offer this explanation, they at least acknowledge the faith’s position, concede the church’s authority, and admit their misalignment with the teaching. In such cases, these individuals are not attempting to manipulate the faith to suit their own interests or telling the church to mind its own business. To do either of these would wrongly suggest that the faith’s teachings are subordinate to an individual’s political preferences.
This is not to say that the church offers precise answers on all political questions. On the contrary. Catholic social teaching recognizes, for instance, that different forms of government are acceptable and that public officials must exercise judgment. Advancing the common good is not formulaic; in many areas, there is room for discussion and disagreement. In fact, the church has a long, proud history of academic engagement in matters of faith, virtue, science, governing, and more.
However, the church doesn’t exist to provide backing for whatever views an individual already holds. Its teachings must be understood as serving to shape, not justify, our positions.
During these polarized times when so many feel angry and unmoored, the church can understandably attract those looking for order, clarity, and authority. As such, some adherents can, unfortunately, attempt to use the faith’s teachings to sacralize their policy preferences and behavior. For instance, regardless of niche discourse, the church does not authorize no-holds-barred political warfare, nor does it support integralism (combining the church with the state).
Vance, who converted to Catholicism in 2019, got into hot water last year when he tried to use Catholic teaching to defend his preferred immigration policy. He was gently corrected by Pope Francis, who explained the true meaning of the concept in question. At about the same time, Vance implied that the nation’s bishops’ views on immigration were financially motivated (a prelate called that charge “scurrilous” and said Vance apologized). In truth, the church has a longstanding and principled position on immigration. A few weeks after these incidents, Vance, to his credit, offered a kind of public mea culpa, calling himself a “baby Catholic” and conceding that he still has things to learn.
Some may also try to sideline the faith when its teachings become inconvenient. They can argue that the church should stick to saving souls and leave questions of governing and policy to others. This is the private-public distinction on steroids. In the latest dust-up, Vance said the pope should leave policy to the president and “stick to matters of morality.” But the church sees policy and morality as entwined: Catholic social teaching understands morality and justice not only at the individual level but at the level of society. In fact, the church has been indispensable to public life, over the last 150 years in particular, because it has not seen morality and governing as distinct. It recognized and articulated the dangers of authoritarianism and the costs of industrialization long before others. It stood against communism. It courageously defended innocent lives, voluntary associations, educational institutions, charities, and more.
I admire Vance for his embrace of the church as an adult. I hope it brings him peace, strength, and meaning. I look forward to his upcoming book on his conversion. I do not question his faith. I hope that we all, myself included, get better at using the church’s teachings to strengthen our thinking about moral and governing matters. This is very different from deciding what we want and then looking to the faith for validation.
More broadly though, these incidents demonstrate that America needs more principles-based leaders. That means those whose political positions flow from values, not those who continuously massage values to justify what they want to do.
Want to see more of The Dispatch in Google search?
Add Us as a Preferred Source



